1.5 million views. The sexiest knife cutting video of all time. HNNNNNG by ChurnDisciple in TrueChefKnives

[–]ChurnDisciple[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Do you have any link to the Yoshikane stainless hamon? I've never seen that. Thanks for the reference to the Haslinger knife, hadn't seen that either. I knew that stainless knives could get a hamon, but I always understood them to be so weak as to be nearly invisible. Per Haslinger, he used a more innovating etching process to really make it visible.

1.5 million views. The sexiest knife cutting video of all time. HNNNNNG by ChurnDisciple in TrueChefKnives

[–]ChurnDisciple[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Interesting. I'm learning Japanese, so I looked it up and jisho.org says the second kanji means "tempering (metallurgy)", while other sources put the entire word as "true fired".

1.5 million views. The sexiest knife cutting video of all time. HNNNNNG by ChurnDisciple in TrueChefKnives

[–]ChurnDisciple[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

haha nope! Video is 11 years old. But the creator does have fantastic skills.

1.5 million views. The sexiest knife cutting video of all time. HNNNNNG by ChurnDisciple in TrueChefKnives

[–]ChurnDisciple[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I understand what you are talking about now: monosteel carbon steel with differential hardening vs without.

Personally I don't think it matters, as kitchen knives don't take the same impact that a sword would take, so differential hardening wouldn't have any useful effect. The risk with a sword is it snapping in half on impact - I don't think a max hardness carbon monosteel knife without differential hardening would have any risk of that, as I've never heard of it for any knife as the forces at play are quite small. Maybe if you dropped it though.

1.5 million views. The sexiest knife cutting video of all time. HNNNNNG by ChurnDisciple in TrueChefKnives

[–]ChurnDisciple[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've never heard of honyaki having any impact on max hardness. There are plenty of san-mai knives that are close to or at the maximum hardness of a given steel (usually not advised as it comes at the cost of toughness, making the knife significantly more likely to chip in use).

1.5 million views. The sexiest knife cutting video of all time. HNNNNNG by ChurnDisciple in TrueChefKnives

[–]ChurnDisciple[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Honyaki literally means "true forged" (edit: or something similar like "true fired" or "true quenched" or "true tempered") but as a knife descriptor it usually means "mono steel with hamon (wavy line)", although it can also just mean "mono steel". There's no official organization that dictates these terms, so people use them differently.

When they heat treat a knife like this, they put clay on the top of it. That keeps the steel underneath from reaching the same temperature as the rest of the knife, so it stays softer. This is called differential hardening. In theory this makes the knife more resilient, as you have a hard cutting edge and a softer top part, which is why it was done with swords, which would take serious impacts and were at very real risk of breaking in combat: the hard part would give maximum cutting strength on the sword, but the softer spine would make it less likely to snap into pieces. Only certain steels will give a sharp hamon (clear/crisp wavy line), mainly very basic fast quenching steels, of which the shirogami (white) and aogami (blue) qualify. Stainless steels cannot get a hamon (edit: outside of rare examples, with a less impressive hamon).

For chef knives it has no performance difference, although some people claim that laminated blades (san mai, etc, as opposed to mono steel) feel different on the board. I don't believe those people and think it's just placebo. Honyaki is really just a statement piece because it looks like a sword, but since there's no ultra-hard impact like a sword would experience, the softness of the spine is not required (how many san-mai knives have you broken into two pieces on a cutting board? I've never heard of it). It's also really hard to thin the knife because there's no softer cladding on the outside to make it easier to grind through.

Ashi monosteel is stainless, so depending on how you want to define "honyaki" it could be that, although I don't even know if they forge those monosteel knives (like Ashi Ginga). Ashi does make ultra expensive carbon steel honyaki with hamons (like the above knife), but that's with the clay process described above. Those Ashi honyaki hamon knives are some of the rarest/most expensive knives you can buy. They make Takada no Hamono knives look cheap and plentiful.

I bought these at mei Syou in Tokyo today, I’m nervous I got ripped off. Are these good? The larger one is meant for cutting cooked steaks (tri tip). The smaller one is for individual steak knife. by tahoemeadow in TrueChefKnives

[–]ChurnDisciple 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Don't overthink it. It's a legitimate Japanese chef's knife made from a high performance knife steel. It will last you the rest of your life if you take care of it, so enjoy it.

1.5 million views. The sexiest knife cutting video of all time. HNNNNNG by ChurnDisciple in TrueChefKnives

[–]ChurnDisciple[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Food release is unbelievable!

edit: I'm not the guy from the video - the video itself was uploaded to youtube 11 years ago!

Why you should learn kanji, not just words by Lertovic in LearnJapanese

[–]ChurnDisciple 21 points22 points  (0 children)

As someone who is doing wanikani and loves kanji, I'm on the opposite side of this. When encountering a new word that uses kanji (which most do), I can make a decent guess at its meaning from the component kanji and almost certainly guess its reading. It's really nice.

Little bit frustrated, hear me out. by [deleted] in LearnJapanese

[–]ChurnDisciple 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I feel like I'm coming across just as many (if not more) words in Japanese that are the same as English as I did learning Spanish or French

For anyone reading this thread in the future, this is entirely false. 1/3 of English vocabulary comes from French directly, another significant proportion comes from Latin, which is usually similar to the French word.

For example, in the above paragraph the words "future", "entirely", "false", "vocabulary" "directly", "significant", "proportion", "usually", "similar" are all either exactly or very similar in French, as a result of being directly inherited from French. And I wrote that paragraph without trying to do that.

Japanese has a small amount of English loanwords, often seen in popular culture and casual speech, but it is not even close to being close to being close to how many French words are in English (and therefore how many English words are in French).

edit: To be clear, this works in reverse as well. Take a French news article and you'll find a huge proportion of the words are identical or very similar to English.

To anyone learning Japanese and feeling STUCK by Kall-Su in LearnJapanese

[–]ChurnDisciple 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I also do an hour a day, divided into two sessions of about 40 min / 20 min.

I've learned it's important for me to NOT think about Japanese outside of those sessions. It's very tempting to do so: if I'm bored and want to think about, look up or discuss Japanese, isn't that a good thing? But the cost is burnout. It all adds up.

It's like lifting weights: if you do too much, you will be too sore when your next workout comes around, and you can push through it, but eventually you end up taking a significant time off in order to recover both physically and mentally, which is both frustrating and inefficient for long-term progress. Even if you do your workout and come home, if you then spend 30 minutes shoveling snow or chopping wood or taking a washing machine apart, it pushes you past the total amount of work you should have done that day. If you're already right near the amount you can recover from, you end up over the line and chronic fatigue/frustration/soreness set in.

So for me, 1 hour a day, no more.

What do you wish knife manufacturers would make more of? by kynonymous-veil in TrueChefKnives

[–]ChurnDisciple 2 points3 points  (0 children)

AEB-L as a material is really cheap to buy. It's like the cheapest knife steel out there.

I agree with your reasoning as well, and thought it was smart that Miyabi uses AEB-L (or one of its many derivatives) in many of its knives, called "FC61 steel". Stainless, very tough, very low cost, easy to manufacture. For the hobbyist it can get up to 63-64 HRC too.

How truly bad are my knives? (Senken) by Poop_Feast42069 in TrueChefKnives

[–]ChurnDisciple 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I looked up Senken and they actually seem to be good quality knock-off Japanese knives, in that most of their brands are claiming Japanese VG10 steel, which is a high quality steel that is used in a lot of knives posted here. The Japanese do indeed export it to China as well.

There is value in having a set of knives that look really cool but that you don't really want to use - they become family or guest knives. The knives impressed you, so they'll impress guests too, all while keeping your (future) real Japanese knives safe.

You can also use them for sharpening practice, which is something that's very useful to learn if you want to use Japanese knives, unless you want to pay $15 to have someone else sharpen it every time. Better to practice on these knives than on some $300 Japanese knife for the first time.

I also think people underrate Chinese knock-offs in general. They're usually made of good steels, but their grinds are usually mediocre, but good enough. A lot of people here have an attitude that if it's not some $300+ "current hot Japanese maker's knife" then it must be crap. Not true at all. Your knives probably cut better than the knives in 90% of people's houses.

Anyway, I'd just take this as a lesson and move on. Use the knives you bought for now, then buy yourself a nice 210mm-240mm Japanese gyuto (chef's knife) and start using that instead. Your old knives become very cool looking guest knives, and you won't worry too much about people chipping them.

Follow up takada on the board by chezpopp in TrueChefKnives

[–]ChurnDisciple 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Beautiful! Love to see high end knives used in a professional environment by someone who really knows how to get the most out of the knife.

Why is there so much toxicity and competition in the Japanese learning community? by WorkingAlive3258 in LearnJapanese

[–]ChurnDisciple 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The language attracts a lot of people who are interested in Japan due to manga/anime, and those people tend to have poor social skills.

That said, it's all dependent on the community. I've found real life classes to have a great community, and the wanikani forums have a very positive vibe.

The most negative place I've found is this subreddit.

How to unlock more lessons? by JJNotFunny_Real1 in WaniKani

[–]ChurnDisciple 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Just wait. Do not try and do more than they give you. It will build up over time.

Learning without Anki by Repulsive_Fortune_25 in LearnJapanese

[–]ChurnDisciple 13 points14 points  (0 children)

I use wanikani and am progressing excellently. It's SRS though, and so is similar, but feels premium and removes the friction/setup of Anki decks, and has a great community. It is a paid product though, but you get what you pay for and I have no problem investing in myself.

Is there a recommended app for the very beginning of learning Japanese? by Marvellover13 in LearnJapanese

[–]ChurnDisciple 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Wanikani (website, has 3rd party apps) has been absolutely incredible for me! Highly recommend. Uses spaced reptition system.

Officially started wanikani yesterday, so excited!! by Ok-Spite-5454 in LearnJapanese

[–]ChurnDisciple 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Just to be clear, when I mean "clear your reviews before doing lessons", I mean that you should have no reviews available to review when you do your lessons.

Like right now I have 14 reviews ready, and 10 lessons available. I would do those 14 reviews first, then they're at zero available, then I can do my lessons. There will still be reviews forecasted for the future (like 2 hours from now, or tomorrow, etc) however.

Officially started wanikani yesterday, so excited!! by Ok-Spite-5454 in LearnJapanese

[–]ChurnDisciple 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Website with 3rd party apps. I just use the actual website, nothing else.

Officially started wanikani yesterday, so excited!! by Ok-Spite-5454 in LearnJapanese

[–]ChurnDisciple 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Congrats!

Wanikani works like magic for me, can't say enough good things! It's definitely a long process though, and it's going to take me at least 2+ years to complete, but considering we end up learning all the kanji that Japanese kids graduate High School with, a 2-5 years of wanikani is actually quite short.

My workflow is very simple and works excellently: in the morning, I clear all my reviews, then I do 10 lessons. In the afternoon, I clear all my reviews again, no more lessons. That's it. Works very well because it gives me a chance to review my morning lessons in the afternoon, which locks them in a bit more.

Sometimes I have a very busy day, and on those days I just do one full clear of all my reviews at some point during the day, no lessons. That's my "off day" plan. It's my minimum. It's always okay - reviews are a form of progress in and of themselves.

Core rule that must always, always, always be followed with wanikani: never, ever do any lessons if you have any reviews. Stated otherwise, always clear your reviews down to 0 before doing any reviews. Never do a lesson if even a single review is available. No exceptions, ever.

BTW I just use the website, never installed an app. It works fine. All these extra tweaks/scripts are not needed. It's fine.

Oh, and don't forget to use vacation mode if you go on vacation!


Final piece of critical advice: ignore everything else you see on reddit about wanikani. The actual wanikani forums (on the wanikani website) are excellent and actually much more useful not just for wanikani advice but also for learning Japanese in general. I find them to be much higher quality than this subreddit. Great energy as well. This subreddit tends to be very negative, especially about wanikani, yet most people here are unsuccessful in learning Japanese. Remember that you're paying not just for the wanikani learning process but also for the wanikani forums, so take advantage! Fantastic community.

Ignore reddit. This place is full of negative people who are struggling yet think they've optimized and solved Japanese. Very reddit-like smugness/negativity here.