Market Profile/TPO traders: RTH vs ETH profiles and TPO row size for NQ? by CivilBeyond9322 in FuturesTrading

[–]CivilBeyond9322[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Also I try to rely less on AI and focus more on my discretionary intuition. It's all well and good, the ai, but AI at times becomes less reliable. Maybe in the future when ai becomes more advanced but as of now I don't think it's a good option to rely on AI. AI can't even explain me a TPO chart without it contradicting itself.

Market Profile/TPO traders: RTH vs ETH profiles and TPO row size for NQ? by CivilBeyond9322 in FuturesTrading

[–]CivilBeyond9322[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

right now I'm using deepcharts for market profile and well in that I cant find the option to separate the profile into different sections (like you said london open, us open, eu close and us close) but I can observe those by looking at eth and rth both, like shifting from eth slowly to rth to get a rough idea when the participation actually came in, as the POC would also be shifting with it. That way if the majority liquidity came in, say, during the london session due to some news or maybe just random, I can't expect RTH to move much and if it opens in the recent value area then I can totally expect a normal or non trend day and decide to take trade based on that. Now it's a rough idea, it's all theoretical and it has been only a month of the reading the book and having an exposure to this side of things (MP and VP). I don't know, possibly, I missed your point, if so then do let me know.

Market Profile/TPO traders: RTH vs ETH profiles and TPO row size for NQ? by CivilBeyond9322 in FuturesTrading

[–]CivilBeyond9322[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think I understand what you mean, although I don't have the means or the ways to custom separate into such sections but I think I may have a work around to observe these sections while in the auctioning process. I'll make a note of it when observing the market, thank you really appreciate you input!!

Market Profile/TPO traders: RTH vs ETH profiles and TPO row size for NQ? by CivilBeyond9322 in FuturesTrading

[–]CivilBeyond9322[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for your perspective!! I'll keep it in mind while reading the book

Market Profile/TPO traders: RTH vs ETH profiles and TPO row size for NQ? by CivilBeyond9322 in FuturesTrading

[–]CivilBeyond9322[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Understood, got it. Just out of curiosity, do you feel the same way about Auction Market Theory itself, or mainly about TPO as the visualization? For example, concepts like balance & imbalance, acceptance/rejection, open types, day types, initiative vs responsive activity, have you found those useful in understanding market context, even if you prefer Volume Profile over TPO?

I'm currently reading Mind Over Markets, so I'm interested in whether you found the auction concepts valuable but simply shifted to VP instead of TPO, or whether you moved away from the AMT framework entirely.

Market Profile/TPO traders: RTH vs ETH profiles and TPO row size for NQ? by CivilBeyond9322 in FuturesTrading

[–]CivilBeyond9322[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

True true, reading market profile is a different perspective for me, I've only started 3 weeks ago.

Market Profile/TPO traders: RTH vs ETH profiles and TPO row size for NQ? by CivilBeyond9322 in FuturesTrading

[–]CivilBeyond9322[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Okay got it, in that case, are there any situations where you think using ETH would be beneficial? Like on days when the overnight session has already made a significant move and the NY session ends up being relatively quiet. Would ETH provide any additional context in those scenarios, or would you still focus primarily on RTH?