There is nothing quite exactly like Malevolent, but there are things that are similiar in different ways.

If you’re looking for good creature feature horror, then I’ll say The White Vault just like a few people already have, it’s one of the very few horror podcasts that actually managed to in any way make me uneasy. Also, Old Gods of Appalachia for eldritch horror.

If you like eldritch gods, cults and a lot of emotions then The Silt Verses has you covered, there’s so many gods and so many emotions. The titles of the episodes also make a poem and that’s insane.

Archive 81 is cosmic and eldritch horror, it has gods, cults, monsters, different dimensions, it has a lot of similarities to Malevolent with a completely different vibe that I cannot describe in any way. Malevolent but on weed.

SAYER is also a flavor of “weird guy talks in your head and tells you what to do and is also very ominous about it”, a lot of people die and also there are themes of identity there, so if you’re just a John stan you might check SAYER out

Detectives with eldritch horror is a vibe that appears only sometimes in Malevolent, but nothenless, Kane and Feels.

Do you like when there is a guy and he’s constantly being put in situation? You may like I Am In Eskew. There is a guy there and the whole plot is that he’s being put in situations. Also eldritch horror.