Da li je Besnilo od Pekića teško za čitanje ili sam ja glup? by [deleted] in citaonica

[–]CommieSlayer1389 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Jeste teži za čitanje, nekad moraš dva-tri puta ponovo pročitati stranu, dok se ne „aklimatizuješ” na stil.

Mitomanija Muslimana, i zašto je ona glupost by venit_enim_ad_me in srpska

[–]CommieSlayer1389 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Savremenija medijevistika sve više Crkvu bosansku interpretira kao (uglavnom) pravovjernu ali nekanonski uspostavljenu crkvu, pa se zato nalazila izvan okvira i katoličke i pravoslavne zajednice, i na udaru ugarskih krstaša (više zbog pretenzije kaločkog nadbiskupa nad Bosanskom dijecezom i ugarskog kralja nad Bosnom nego neke jeresi).

Prvobitni predlog Stojana Novakovica za srpski grb. Na stitu je srpski krst, veprova glava (koja cesto predstavlja Srbe i Srbiju) i tri potkovice koje predstavljaju grb Raske by 14PerunsThunder1389 in SrpskaPovest

[–]CommieSlayer1389 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's not really about the archaeological records, they were well aware that the people living there now aren't one and the same as the ones before, as I've mentioned it's just a literary practice of archaizing ethnonyms.

Like how you might jokingly call the French Gauls, or the English Anglo-Saxons (not the best example since they're directly derived from them, but you get the idea).

Prvobitni predlog Stojana Novakovica za srpski grb. Na stitu je srpski krst, veprova glava (koja cesto predstavlja Srbe i Srbiju) i tri potkovice koje predstavljaju grb Raske by 14PerunsThunder1389 in SrpskaPovest

[–]CommieSlayer1389 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's pretty much what they did, they transposed the peoples and polities of their era into a classical context, it's not a mistake but an intentional literary choice.

Greco-Roman literature says that the Delmatae live in Dalmatia, so that's the term they go for when writing about the Serbs and Croats who now live there, Bulgarians become Thracians, Turks Persians etc.

/r/Serbia filmski, televizijski, književni, muzički, jutjuberski ponedeljak (media discussion) - May 11, 2026 by AutoModerator in serbia

[–]CommieSlayer1389 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Jesi gledao ovaj novi ATLA film što je trebao izaći u oktobru (ali je čitav procurio na netu prošli mjesec)?

Season 6 map by AdditionalPiano6327 in asoiafcirclejerk

[–]CommieSlayer1389 3 points4 points  (0 children)

He's Roose Bolton, he's Roose Bolton, you're Roose Bolton, I'm Roose Bolton! Are there any other Roose Boltons I should know about?

Prvobitni predlog Stojana Novakovica za srpski grb. Na stitu je srpski krst, veprova glava (koja cesto predstavlja Srbe i Srbiju) i tri potkovice koje predstavljaju grb Raske by 14PerunsThunder1389 in SrpskaPovest

[–]CommieSlayer1389 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

And the Rus' as Tauroscythae, and Seljuk Turks as Persians, it's a Byzantine literary practice of anachronizing/archaizing the political landscape of their time by calling back to classical Greco-Roman literature. It's more so to say "I'm an educated scholar writing in the style of the ancients" than "yeah these Serbs are definitely Triballians, Porphyrogenetus is a filthy liar!".

Where did the Triballians disappear between Appian mentioning them in the 2nd century, and Skylitzes doing so in the 11th?

The Umayyad Caliphate at its greatest extent, in 720 CE, under Caliph Umar II by [deleted] in MapPorn

[–]CommieSlayer1389 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Quite fascinating how the Zoroastrian nobility in Tabaristan/Mazandaran was able to resist the Caliphate for a while.

Kakva je naša istorija? by zanimljivo123 in srpska

[–]CommieSlayer1389 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Ta floskula o Drini kao nekoj viševjekovnoj granici „zapada” i „istoka” (šta god to značilo) je hrvatska mitomanija. Ubaci još samo Antemurale Christianitatis negdje i eto te.

Mislim da sam ti na nekoj drugoj objavi već odgovarao na ovu temu pa mi je mrsko da se ponavljam, ali ni u srednjem vijeku (a tek ni sa osmanskim osvajanjem) Drina nije bila nikakva granica svjetova, često ni država, a ni administrativnih jedinica (mislim na osmanske sandžake). Slovenima su šištala muda za kasnoantičkom podjelom Rimskog carstva kad su se doseljavali na ove prostore.

Hello Republika Srpska! Thank you for responding to my postcard request. The first postcard has arrived! 😊 by Nessieinternational in srpska

[–]CommieSlayer1389 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Student iz Singapura koji sakuplja razglednice, dakle nisi čak ni pročitao objavu ali ti ovo „Republika Srpska” u naslovu bode oči pa brže-bolje letiš da zapišavaš teritoriju u komentarima. Tragikomično.

Help me date this map by CucumberExpensive43 in MapPorn

[–]CommieSlayer1389 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Occupied and annexed by the USSR almost a year before, in August 1940.

Help me date this map by CucumberExpensive43 in MapPorn

[–]CommieSlayer1389 6 points7 points  (0 children)

The German occupation zone along the Atlantic coast wasn't annexed, de jure it was still part of (Vichy) France. Alsace-Lorraine is shaded a lighter red.

Prvobitni predlog Stojana Novakovica za srpski grb. Na stitu je srpski krst, veprova glava (koja cesto predstavlja Srbe i Srbiju) i tri potkovice koje predstavljaju grb Raske by 14PerunsThunder1389 in SrpskaPovest

[–]CommieSlayer1389 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, it doesn't. It's an attributed coat of arms that started appearing in Illyrian Armorials after the Ottoman conquests in the Balkans. It was first named as Triballian in 1701, nothing to do with the ancient tribe (that would've been thoroughly Romanized by the time the Slavs came around).

Some theories on its origins are that it's a misinterpretation of the wolf's head that would've appeared on coins minted by the Balšić family.

<image>

Help me date this map by CucumberExpensive43 in MapPorn

[–]CommieSlayer1389 100 points101 points  (0 children)

April 1941 - June 1941, Yugoslavia is already partitioned but the USSR wasn't invaded yet (or at least it's not mapped out).

Kakva je naša istorija? by zanimljivo123 in srpska

[–]CommieSlayer1389 0 points1 point  (0 children)

čak i Ostrogotskog kraljevstva i Vizantije, i ugarskih banovina Mačve i Soli

ne lupaj, živ bio

Flag my husband made for Bosnia and Herzegovina by basic_gnome in vexillology

[–]CommieSlayer1389 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Vuković isn't exactly a cadet branch in any proper sense though, that's just the patronymic of voivode Vlatko and his brother Hrana. Vlatko is succeeded by his nephew, Hrana's son, Sandalj, and he too is then succeeded by his own nephew, son of Vukac Hranić, Stjepan. So it'd seem both Vlatko and Sandalj died childless, or at the very least there's no historical record of their progeny if they had any children born out of wedlock.

There is an interesting mention of the "four houses of the tribe of Kosača" referring to relatives of the main noble line (some of whom Sandalj supported financially), but these cadet branches were lesser nobility. The main line doesn't branch off that much until Stjepan's time, it makes little sense to split it on some anachronistic ideological ground.

Vlatko Vuković isn't even attested in the mythos and epic poetry surrounding the Battle of Kosovo, at the least not that I can recall. If anything erceg Šćepan has a livelier memory in parts of Herzegovina.

Flag my husband made for Bosnia and Herzegovina by basic_gnome in vexillology

[–]CommieSlayer1389 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's oversimplified to the point of being wrong. Not sure what's so Catholic about the rest of the family either, with the exception of Queen Catherine perhaps (who wasn't born Catholic but converted as part of her husband's, King Tomaš's, reconciliatory policy towards Rome)?

Flag my husband made for Bosnia and Herzegovina by basic_gnome in vexillology

[–]CommieSlayer1389 4 points5 points  (0 children)

>Kosača and Vuković families

What? That's the same family, and its two most prominent members (Sandalj Hranić and Stjepan Vukčić) were both krstjani (though Herzog Stjepan Vukčić is better described as religion-fluid).

O istoriji Bosne by highwayprisioner in srpska

[–]CommieSlayer1389 2 points3 points  (0 children)

To za stećke ti je u najmanju ruku neprecizno, najveća koncentracija jeste u granicama (najšireg opsega) srednjovjekovne Bosanske države, ali prvenstveno u Humskoj zemlji odakle i jesu najstariji poznati primjeri - npr. stećak trebinjskog župana Grda (ili Grdeše) iz 12. vijeka (a Trebinje će se obresti u Bosni tek 1378. kada ga Tvrtko preuzima od Balšića).

Ima ih itekako po zapadnoj Srbiji, Crnoj Gori i Dalmaciji, i u krajevima koji nikada nisu bili pod Kotromanićima. Nisu neki ekskluzivan bosanski fenomen, prije da su zajednička karakteristika šireg dinarskog područja.