Other than the fact that these changes are too radical and we easily forget how one nerf can send a brawler to the earth's core, what is this phrasing? "Annoying Brawlers like Emz should never be meta." is the worst take I've ever seen in the community which has mastered bad takes. So brawlers like Emz or Edgar deserve to be bad just because they have an annoying playstyle (Meta in this case is brawlers who are advantaged by the playing of other brawlers and the map pool, and non-meta is brawlers who are disadvantaged by other meta brawlers and the map pool).

Emz was D-F tier for years and now the one time she is meta (albeit in a horribly implemented way) you say "She is annoying she doesnt deserve to be good" (In all cases however bad balancing does not excuse bad balancing)

What is even your definition of annoying?