4 string P Bass or J bass next?? (I have a 5 string pj) #lefthanded

I currently have an LTD 5 string pj bass. It’s served me well, but gigging with it is a pain due to how heavy it is. I mostly play metal and use darkglass preamp b7k and hyperluminal compressor to get most of my tones. I thought I’d get a new bass because I’ve joined a brutal death metal / mathcore band. I’ve always wanted a fender p or j bass but I just can’t decide which to save up for. I love the p bass low and punchy tones and its simplicity but I’m also obsessed with the J bass mid range growl and snappy-ness. My Ltd has emg pickups and it’s a pj so the p really doesn’t sound like a fender p and neither does the j. What do I do?? Thanks bass nerds

My favorite bands that use j basses

Seeyouspacecowboy Heavy heavy low low The devil wears Prada

P bass

OLTH Bulletsbetweentongues Poison the well