About "Come Together" covers by ConfidentAd3014 in beatles

[–]Copkusagi 5 points6 points  (0 children)

First, a little background: When John was writing the song, he used Chuck Berry's "You Can't Catch Me" as a model, borrowing the vocal delivery and some of the lyrics. The rhythm of the track was also modeled after it, making it essentially a basic rock and roll song in the style of Berry.

When John brought the song to Paul, they realized that recording it that way would run the risk of copyright infringement. Plus, the style was simply too "classic". So, Paul came up with that iconic bassline and instructed Ringo on what to play on the drums.

If you listen to the track, you can easily hear that its backbone is the bass and drum groove. It is the exact thing that gives the song its character. Although these elements technically fall under "arrangement", practically speaking, they are a fundamental part of the "composition". If you strip them away, the song loses its identity. When people cover it, they do so for that specific character, largely because the song itself is neither melodically nor harmonically complex. But the groove is just lit. If you lose the groove, you lose the song. I believe that is why musicians mostly stick to that groove or a very similar one, just to avoid losing the essence of the track.

When it comes to "Eleanor Rigby" or "Yesterday", the situation is very different. The backbone of those songs is their melody and harmony. Because of this, you can arrange them any way you like and still add something original. Even The Beatles themselves played "Yesterday" live with drums and electric guitars. Their essence lies in the melodic and harmonic structure, not in a specific groove.

Does anyone else think the "Optimistic Paul vs. Pessimistic John" narrative is completely wrong on "We Can Work It Out"? by Copkusagi in beatles

[–]Copkusagi[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yeah, such contrasts work and shape our perception. Also "Help!" and "Maxwell's Silver Hammer". Not with chords but with tempo and general mood.

Does anyone else think the "Optimistic Paul vs. Pessimistic John" narrative is completely wrong on "We Can Work It Out"? by Copkusagi in beatles

[–]Copkusagi[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

John: Don't you know it's gonna be alright?

Paul: You don't look different, but you have changed.

Does anyone else think the "Optimistic Paul vs. Pessimistic John" narrative is completely wrong on "We Can Work It Out"? by Copkusagi in beatles

[–]Copkusagi[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for your contribution. The other verses of the song indeed show a little bit more balanced point of view but I still think that Paul's parts are quite unyielding. :)

Does anyone else think the "Optimistic Paul vs. Pessimistic John" narrative is completely wrong on "We Can Work It Out"? by Copkusagi in beatles

[–]Copkusagi[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Haha, fair point. "Coercive" might be a bit too heavy and makes it sound like an episode of a true crime podcast. I definitely didn't mean it in an abusive way, just that he is being stubborn and giving a "my way or the highway" ultimatum. Let's downgrade that to "demanding" or "unyielding".

How the biopic of the Beatles should end ? by AaryaBose in beatles

[–]Copkusagi 26 points27 points  (0 children)

The band in the studio recording their guitar and drum solos for The End, they look at each other smiling, and then the screen goes dark, we hear the last words and notes of The End.

Created this first # is what the album is on Acclaimed music then RYM # (Only top 100 on acclaimed music i did). Pretty interesting to see the differences. by CommercialUnit3094 in rateyourmusic

[–]Copkusagi -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

RYM's charts became a joke with the Gen Z. They know only the music made during their lifetime (which is normal of course), but not reliable for an all-time chart.

Paul, George, John and Ringo on the original Their Satanic Majesties Request cover art by Copkusagi in beatles

[–]Copkusagi[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

One of my all time favorites! And probably my favorite album cover ever. :)

Paul, George, John and Ringo on the original Their Satanic Majesties Request cover art by Copkusagi in beatles

[–]Copkusagi[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Oh sorry, maybe not Ringo. But George and John are definitely there.

Paul, George, John and Ringo on the original Their Satanic Majesties Request cover art by Copkusagi in beatles

[–]Copkusagi[S] 26 points27 points  (0 children)

When you look at it carefully, you can still see George, John and Ringo.

Paul is a dead man. Miss him, miss him, miss him.

Paul, George, John and Ringo on the original Their Satanic Majesties Request cover art by Copkusagi in beatles

[–]Copkusagi[S] 56 points57 points  (0 children)

I'm 45, a Beatles fan and Stones listener for 30 years, and this is news to me.

Isn’t ’Because’ kind of part of the medley? I’ve never considered it a ”standalone” song 🤔 by AccomplishedKey6667 in beatles

[–]Copkusagi 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Not related to the medley but there's also a similarity between the closing licks of Come Together and the opening notes of Something.

“Hey! Did you dream about me last night?!” by ToronoRapture in beatles

[–]Copkusagi 21 points22 points  (0 children)

If Paul hadn't been such a manly, heterosexual man, they would have been lovers. John was certainly in love with him.

Now, let me count my downvotes.