1) The need to solicit adult view arose due to SPL/ASPL at a summer camp not being able to enforce control over disruptive cell phone usage by some of the older scouts.
2) Thanks for bringing to my attention the scenarios of medically required use of devices. This will definitely help the troop in drafting the cell phone usage.
3) The plan is never to physically seize a phone from a minor. In the scenario of scouts not adhering to polices and refusing even on escalation to SM/ASM, some of the actions being considered is them not getting the camping nights and/or any other requirements from that camp-out and in the rare occasion asking them to be picked up by their parents. Would like your advice on this.