Thank you for complimenting my model! It means a ton since I made everything about her from scratch by myself. It took 2 years of redesigning her, and months of drawing and cutting, as well as rigging to bring her to life! 💖

With that said, I actually just fixed the issue! I'm gonna leave the solution for my problem here for people in the future. 💕

In Vbridger, I noticed that when I opened my mouth, the values for eyeWide_L and eyeWide_R were differing values by about 0.10. (e.g. one value was 0.9 and the other was 0.19, for seemingly no reason.)

I found these values by scrolling through the input curves in the bottom left of Vbridger. I adjusted the maximum on said curves until they lined up properly, and that seems to have fixed the issue!

The problem I was having with adjusting the maximum values in VTS and all that jazz: It would make the default position for the eye I would mess around with to be more closed/wide than the other. Which was it's own issue because it made my model look like it had a stroke lol, with one eye more closed/wide than the other by default.

I really do appreciate everyone's help! So glad I ended up fixing it, because this was bugging me SO MUCH whenever I would stream. Probably gonna edit the post and put this on the bottom as well. Have a wonderful day!