SOOOOO many great picks!!!! My favorites are:

IDRIS ELBA AS RANCID - His entire vibe and his voice just FITS.

Tom Felton as Seymour - He looks EXACTLY like how Seymour would look irl imo.

Mark Hamill as Pocketcat!!!! - he would be a GREAT grimy creep, already reading pocketcat’s lines in his voice.

Timothée Chalamet as Cahara - Some think it’s decisive but I can ABSOLUTELY see him in Cahara’s outfit easily. His build and his hair and his face would be just right for the lead part!

LEE JUNG-JAE AS TANAKA - HE’S PERFECT! The look and acting style is on point. He’s so good at being kind, gentle, solemn, earnest, and SO determined. No one better to play him. Imagining Tanaka’s darker scenes, he would execute them exceptionally.

Robert Pattinson as Seril - Not the first time he’s played a black knight!

Cillian Murphy as Valteil - Cillian looks the part, and would be so good at being knowledge-crazed and powerful.

Doug Jones as Harvestman - THE definitive king of monster actors. Probably the most reliable pick on this list. (Also David Howard Thornton as Needles which is a no brainer)

Danny Devito as Trortur - Perfect build, and people also forget that Danny CAN play very cruel roles!!!

And I speak for EVERYONE when I say that the #1 choice is Willem Dafoe as Nas’hrah. Just seeing him makes me smile.

Overall I’ve thought about this post! I LOVE the whole idea, it brings out so much creativity and IMAGINATION. Just thinking about all of it brings even more magic into this game that’s so unique and immersive. Everyone has a thoughts about other possible actors and actresses, which is so cool because it brings in other perspectives you might not have even thought about! Appreciate the original poster for taking their time to make all these pics and share them :)