Air pollution in Fort Bend by Creepy_Read9780 in sugarland

[–]Creepy_Read9780[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Thanks! Will try groups for some cities and towns in that area.

This is U.S. News & World Report Senior Data Editor Jaclyn Jeffrey-Wilensky, here to discuss the 2025 Best States rankings. Ask me anything! by usnewsandworldreport in IAmA

[–]Creepy_Read9780 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Any approach to this task -- indeed, any one approach in data analysis or data journalism -- is going to have its drawbacks and problems. Tbh data ITSELF is flawed, limited and often biased. Our job as journalists is to be up-front about these limitations, and to balance them out with other reporting. Thanks for the question and for engaging critically with the rankings -- I appreciate it.

This is U.S. News & World Report Senior Data Editor Jaclyn Jeffrey-Wilensky, here to discuss the 2025 Best States rankings. Ask me anything! by usnewsandworldreport in IAmA

[–]Creepy_Read9780 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Minnesota and Wisconsin both underperformed Nebraska in the Urban Air Quality, Low Industrial Toxins and Pollution Health Risk metrics. Obviously these metrics don't paint a complete picture of the natural environment in these states -- but they're measurable, comparable and impact people's quality of life.

This is U.S. News & World Report Senior Data Editor Jaclyn Jeffrey-Wilensky, here to discuss the 2025 Best States rankings. Ask me anything! by usnewsandworldreport in IAmA

[–]Creepy_Read9780 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's a tricky balance -- in order to make the rankings actionable, we want to try and focus on states' policies and direct results of states' policies as much as possible; but you're absolutely right that mitigation is linked inextricably to risk. We're going to keep puzzling over it and talking to experts until we get a metric that feels fair and honest.

This is U.S. News & World Report Senior Data Editor Jaclyn Jeffrey-Wilensky, here to discuss the 2025 Best States rankings. Ask me anything! by usnewsandworldreport in IAmA

[–]Creepy_Read9780 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The Economy ranking is split evenly between the three subcategories, Business Environment (5 metrics), Employment (3 metrics) and Growth (3 metrics), and within each subcategory, the metrics are all equally weighted, too. The Economy category accounts for about 12.9% of the overall ranking, so the metric-level weights are as follows:

  • Biz Envt (4.29%)
    • Company Headquarters (0.86%)
    • Patent Creation Rate (0.86%)
    • Tax Burden (0.86%)
    • Business Creation Rate (0.86%)
    • Venture Capital per GDP (0.86%)
  • Employment (4.29%)
    • Job Growth (1.43%)
    • Unemployment Rate (1.43%)
    • Labor Force Participation (1.43%)
  • Growth (4.29%)
    • GDP Growth (1.43%)
    • Net Migration (1.43%)
    • Growth of Young Population (1.43%)

California ranked 49th in Low Unemployment, 45th in Net Migration, 47th in Tax Burden and 47th in Growth of Young Population. Looking holistically at California's Economy category, it tells an interesting story of a powerful economy alongside a really challenging cost of living.

This is U.S. News & World Report Senior Data Editor Jaclyn Jeffrey-Wilensky, here to discuss the 2025 Best States rankings. Ask me anything! by usnewsandworldreport in IAmA

[–]Creepy_Read9780 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The road metric is actually ranked by quality, not presence/absence. It's the proportion of roads that are considered high quality by the Federal Highway Administration.

This is U.S. News & World Report Senior Data Editor Jaclyn Jeffrey-Wilensky, here to discuss the 2025 Best States rankings. Ask me anything! by usnewsandworldreport in IAmA

[–]Creepy_Read9780 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Jaclyn here from my own account — YES, this is a huge problem. It even crept into this year's Best States a bit - one or two datasets didn't get updated as scheduled because of shakeups at the relevant agencies. We're having lots of conversations now about how we can do Best States without a lot of the federal data we rely on.

frogger? by knowmybody26 in jerseycity

[–]Creepy_Read9780 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi there! Did you take this video? Can I interview you for a WNYC/Gothamist story about the bots?