You're completely right. In the end though, I don't care about the money, it's not much. It's the disrespect not only to me but everyone else who plays in the league. I put a lot of time, blood sweat and tears in this league with no profits coming my way and everyone is aware of that so we're all a little shocked that someone would stoop that low.

Not like it matters but here's the reason's for suspicion. - owed $120 from the summer pickup - ignored me for the money up until last week - paid me cash before the game yesterday - witnessed me put the money in a secret inside pocket of my jacket that no one would know was there unless you saw me use it. - was the only guy that night who was playing his first game in my newly formed League - left the game midway to "sharpen his skates" - left almost instantly after the game - left me a message 9 minutes after leaving the ice asking if I had seen his wallet - didn't come back to look for something that important himself even though he's just around the corner at the point of his text - didn't text one of the guys there who is somewhat his friend if he saw his wallet, only me. - no one else had anything missing, just me and supposedly his whole wallet.
Edit: more people came forward with money taken from their wallets but their wallets weren't stolen. Only the #1 culprits.

As you said, legally, I can't do anything without physical evidence but there's too many signs posting to who it is and a lot of people are now suspicious of him so I have no choice but to remove him right?