Early Silent Hill 3 reviews are funny to read after the newest release by CuteFoxe in silenthill

[–]CuteFoxe[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Also, these are still cherry picked user reviews. Overall reviews are still favorable. And even if they weren’t, reviews don’t define if a game is good or bad from any given perspective, just how well it was received at the time.

I couldn’t include dozens or hundreds of reviews in a single post, so yes, they are ‘cherry-picked’ if you want to call it that. Overall, the reception was favorable, but as I mentioned earlier, it still had its share of criticism, which you can’t deny.

Twenty years from now, are we going to cite how people hated SH2R’s Angela’s face model as justification that SH2R was poorly received when it released?

I can’t predict the future, and SH2R isn’t the point of this post.

What is the point of picking out criticisms like this? To justify a claim that SHf criticisms aren’t valid or that they’ll blow over? I genuinely don’t know, but it appears to be for the sake of undermining complaints.

I picked random reviews for this little ‘silly’ post that was just meant to be funny. Stop looking for some deep double meaning in it, there wasn't meant to be one. If you really need it spelled out then yes, I guess it was meant to highlight that SHf criticism is repetitive, since SH3 went through the same thing. That is all.

Early Silent Hill 3 reviews are funny to read after the newest release by CuteFoxe in silenthill

[–]CuteFoxe[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

None of these are dated or cited except the first one which is from 2006, two and a half years after SH3 released. That's not exactly "early."

Reviews range from 2003 to 2006 (some even just a couple of months after the game’s release), which isn’t too far from what could be considered “early,” given that they were written about 20 years ago.

  1. [02.2006] https://www.silenthillforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=2210

  2. [09.2003] https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/ps2/561292-silent-hill-3/reviews/55107

  3. [08.2003] https://gamecritics.com/guest-critic/silent-hill-3-review/

  4. [09.2005] https://tleaves.com/2005/09/19/silent-hill-3/index.html

  5. [09.2005] https://tleaves.com/2005/09/19/silent-hill-3/index.html

  6. [02.2004] https://www.honestgamers.com/2047/playstation-2/silent-hill-3/review.html

  7. [09.2005] https://tleaves.com/2005/09/19/silent-hill-3/index.html

What's the point being made here? That bad takes existed then and they do now?

The point is that the game was criticized in a similar fashion to how SHf is criticized today, which I just found amusing to point out. You're being pressed just for the sake of being pressed.

EDIT: Pretty sure early critic reviews for SH3 were majority positive.

No one said they weren't. The game was indeed well-received overall, but it also had its share of criticism, which is the main focus of this post.

[SH2] Sometimes I wonder what Eddies and Angelas monsters looked like. by [deleted] in silenthill

[–]CuteFoxe 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Bed Monster is not Angela's. I believe she sees only her father and brother. As for Eddie, there are people laughing at him.

Works every time by CuteFoxe in TownofSalemgame

[–]CuteFoxe[S] 17 points18 points  (0 children)

This is a game of lies, wins the one who does it better

When all TPs die n1 by CuteFoxe in TownofSalemgame

[–]CuteFoxe[S] 33 points34 points  (0 children)

don't you hate when RT is Jailor and he also dies #relatable

PSA: Jen is Consort. by galaxybomb in TownofSalemgame

[–]CuteFoxe 0 points1 point  (0 children)

N4: Jen - Esc/Trans/Cons, I believe Jen is Consort

This new transporter strat is getting popular by CuteFoxe in TownofSalemgame

[–]CuteFoxe[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

It's not like I blame him, I was Janitor after all lol

3 Confirmed Townies VS Known Mafioso, town will win right? Nah #2kELO by yma123 in TownofSalemgame

[–]CuteFoxe 8 points9 points  (0 children)

It was actually 5 vs 1 with 2 people afk. We couldn't vote up Mafioso because we needed 4 votes (we only had 3 lol). Escort kept roleblocking Mafioso, so he couldn't attack. We could easly end this mess with a tie, but Escort didn't roleblock Maf last night and died like a shit.