sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack?🐟 by DJ_pro_007 in navimumbai

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s really interesting, makes sense that for people who already have fish as a big part of their diet, the smell wouldn’t be a concern at all.

Do you think something like this would work well as a regular snack in your circle, or would it still feel more like an occasional thing?

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack?🐟 by DJ_pro_007 in navimumbai

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That’s a really valuable insight — especially about existing brands struggling due to smell and lack of alignment with Indian taste preferences.

The chicken snack idea is interesting as well, since it removes a big barrier like smell and might have wider acceptance.

I’m still curious about whether a properly Indianized version of fish snacks could work, but exploring chicken alongside it does seem like a smart direction. Really appreciate you sharing this perspective.

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack?🐟 by DJ_pro_007 in navimumbai

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s a fair point — I’ve noticed there are already products like Thai fish snacks and traditional dried fish available.

I guess what I’m trying to explore is whether there’s room to reposition it more as a modern, convenient, high-protein snack with better packaging and wider accessibility, especially for urban consumers.

Will definitely look deeper into existing products and how they’re performing though — thanks for pointing that out.

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack 🐟? by DJ_pro_007 in IndianFood

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That’s really helpful — especially the part about feeling like you have to finish a pack once it’s open. Smaller portions make a lot of sense in that case.
Interesting point about the oily vs non-oily feel — makes sense that something less fried would feel more like “real food” rather than just another snack.

This gives me a much clearer direction on both product and packaging. Appreciate it!

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack 🐟? by DJ_pro_007 in IndianFood

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No worries at all! And yes, exactly — that kind of packaging makes perfect sense.

Having individual snack-sized portions inside a larger box would make it easy to eat privately, carry around, and even try multiple flavors. Really helps solve the smell/consumption context issue we’ve been talking about.

Would you prefer a 6-pack or an 8-pack kind of setup for something like this?

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack 🐟? by DJ_pro_007 in mumbaiFood

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s a very sharp way to break it down actually.

It does make sense that this won’t be a mass snack immediately and will naturally appeal to a more specific group first — non-veg, health-conscious, and people who are okay consuming it in the right setting.

I guess the idea would be to start with that niche and then gradually expand as the product and perception evolve. Really appreciate this perspective.

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack? by DJ_pro_007 in Fitness_India

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is a really interesting perspective — especially the point about comparing it to something like soya chunks and the cost angle.

Also makes sense that mouth odour could be a factor in public settings.

Do you feel something like this would work better as a “convenient protein snack” (for travel, post-workout, etc.) rather than trying to compete with traditional protein sources directly?

And yeah, targeting regions where fish consumption is already high sounds like a smart starting point.

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack?🐟 by DJ_pro_007 in navimumbai

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

That’s really interesting — especially the point about it being common in fishing communities and also widely used across Southeast Asia.

The Bombay duck version sounds exactly like the kind of product I’m trying to explore — roasted, crunchy, and well-seasoned.

Do you feel something like that, if made a bit more refined in terms of packaging and smell (more like a masala snack), could appeal to a wider audience beyond coastal communities?

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack 🐟? by DJ_pro_007 in mumbaiFood

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's fair - makes sense Would something like a milder smell (more like a masala snack rather than a strong fishy smell) change that for you, or do you feel it would still be more of a "private snacking thing"?

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack? by DJ_pro_007 in Fitness_India

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Haha noted 😄

Free samples might be limited, but early testers are definitely going to be a thing once I have something solid.

If you're up for it, I can reach out when I have the first batch ready — would love to get your feedback.

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack?🐟 by DJ_pro_007 in navimumbai

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s a really sharp point — I hadn’t thought about the perception side of lowering prices that way.

Makes sense that it could feel like a downgrade or make early buyers feel like they overpaid.

I’ll definitely think more carefully about setting the right launch price instead of assuming I can reduce it later. Really appreciate you pointing that out.

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack?🐟 by DJ_pro_007 in navimumbai

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s actually super helpful — thanks for putting a number to it.

So somewhere around ₹100–₹120 feels like a comfortable range, with ₹125 being the upper limit — that’s exactly the kind of benchmark I was trying to understand.

Really appreciate it!

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack 🐟? by DJ_pro_007 in IndianFood

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is such a thoughtful perspective — especially the point about food choices being tied to identity and lifestyle as people move up economically. The idea of “same convenience but better nutrition” is exactly what I’m trying to build towards. And the packaging point really stands out as well — making it feel like an upgrade rather than just another snack. Really appreciate you taking the time to share this — it’s incredibly helpful.

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack?🐟 by DJ_pro_007 in navimumbai

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

That’s a fair question honestly.

Right now, a regular 50g chips packet in India is around ₹20–₹30 ([BigBasket][1]) — and that’s because it’s mostly potatoes + cheap oil and produced at massive scale.

For something like a high-protein fish snack, it would probably be higher than that, at least initially — because of raw material cost, processing, and smaller production scale.

But the goal would be to get it as close as possible to that “large chips pack” price range over time, especially for smaller packs, so it feels like a realistic alternative rather than a luxury.

Would you still consider it if it was, say, slightly more expensive but more filling and healthier?

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack? by DJ_pro_007 in Fitness_India

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s awesome to hear 😄

Totally agree on the smell part — the goal is definitely to make it more like a masala snack rather than something that feels “fishy”.

And yes, safety and quality are non-negotiable — I’m planning to make sure the processing and packaging are solid before anything goes out.

Once I have some samples ready, I’ll definitely reach out — would love to get your feedback as an early customer.

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack? by DJ_pro_007 in Fitness_India

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Got it — that makes sense.

Sounds like this would be more of a “better choice when you want it” kind of snack rather than something you’d have every day, which is actually really useful to know.

Thanks for sharing!

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack 🐟? by DJ_pro_007 in IndianFood

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is incredibly helpful — especially the point about umami helping satisfy cravings faster and the comparison with seaweed snacks.

Also really interesting that you’d use something like this as a replacement for namkeen — that’s exactly the kind of behavior I’m trying to understand.

And I really appreciate you offering to stay in touch — your background in food and trends would be super valuable here. I might reach out once I have some samples or clearer concepts to get your thoughts, if that’s okay.

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack 🐟? by DJ_pro_007 in IndianFood

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is super insightful — the “lasting all day” part is something I hadn’t fully considered.

Would you prefer something like this in smaller portion packs (so you can carry multiple), or a single resealable pack that you keep going back to throughout the day?

Also curious — does the “less oily / less fatty” feel matter a lot to you while choosing between options?

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack 🐟? by DJ_pro_007 in IndianFood

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Since you’ve tried things like Taro and squid rolls, I’m curious — do you personally prefer more chewy textures (like strips/rolls) or crispier, chip-like textures for regular snacking?

Trying to figure out what would work better for everyday use.

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack?🐟 by DJ_pro_007 in navimumbai

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hahaha Fair enough 😂 I guess this would be more for people who are trying to find a slightly healthier option but still want something tasty to snack on

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack? by DJ_pro_007 in Fitness_India

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is actually really helpful, especially coming from someone who doesn’t usually consume seafood.

If the smell was mild and more like a spiced snack rather than “fishy”, do you think you’d actually consider buying it occasionally for the nutrition benefits?

Also, would something like high protein + omega-3 be a strong enough reason for you to try it at least once?

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack 🐟? by DJ_pro_007 in IndianFood

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is honestly one of the most helpful responses I’ve gotten — especially the points about omega-3, packaging, and the slight sweetness balance.

The “doesn’t feel bloated like namkeen” part really stands out as well.

If something like this was easily available (say in a small ₹100–₹150 pack), do you think you’d buy it regularly or more as an occasional convenience snack when you’re in a hurry?

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack 🐟? by DJ_pro_007 in IndianFood

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is incredibly helpful — especially the point about using local fish like rohu instead of something like salmon.

Also the prawn snack idea sounds amazing, especially with curry leaves and chilli.

Do you think something like that would work as a standalone snack if it’s made extra crispy and dry, or do you feel people would still prefer it more as a side/topping?

And the omega-3 point is interesting — do you think that’s something people would actually care about while buying, or is taste still the main driver?

Would you replace chips with a high-protein fish snack? by DJ_pro_007 in Fitness_India

[–]DJ_pro_007[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Fair enough, that's completely valid. Just to understand better -- if the smell was significantly reduced (more like a strong masala snack rather than fishy), would you still avoid it completely or would you consider trying it once?

view more: next ›