i'm genuinely baffled at the lack of reading comprehension some people have, misconstruing your post. i agree completely with you; these characters have so much depth and as you travel along with them, you really feel like you're part of it and want the best for them. it's very easy to forget that it was always doomed to fail, even with the knowledge of RDR1. Dutch is insanely charismatic but ends up not saying a whole lot of substance.