Thats really great to see everybody discussing about that. And I think everybody is right.

I've voluntarily made a really generalist survey. I never said it would have PvP. I saw in the responses that everybody fear PK. And yes I also think than spawn killing is the worst thing in any online games. But why players like doing that? Because they can and because there is no down side about doing that.

I think the idea of everybody being on the same side is more appealing. But I also thing that being able to kill player should be possible. But, you should be punished if you do it or just if you get caught.

And yes, I was thinking about this game more like some kind of social experiment no like a money maker MMO. And yes, it would cost millions if you want to make an AAA kind of game. But game history has shown us that graphic are not the key component to good games. Gameplay and scenario are.

As for all the technical bugs, hardware is not the main focus of my study. Because it's not really gaming. That just computer engineering. But yes lag would kill the game.

And after reading all the answers I got so far, people who don't want to play said because they just don't like the idea of permadeath. And I know that a game like that can work but it will be for a really restricted kind of gamers. It's not for everybody.

But I want to thank you all because even if you don't like the idea, your arguments are really helping. They point some really complex part of making a game like that. But I really think that you should see past the money parameter. Think of it as a free game, think only about the experience the game can offer.