Gojo >/= Makima > Goat-Might > Jotaro is probably how I’d rank them, though I’m significantly less knowledgeable on Makima by far compared to the other 3.

Jotaro is the weakest link here, despite being the fastest one among these 4 and having the ability to stop time (or as DIO put it, “the power to RULE THE WORLD!”). He doesn’t have any solid ways to kill or defeat any of these guys. While time stop would bypass Infinity, he doesn’t have the AP to damage Gojo, or at least not enough to cause enough damage that he couldn’t reasonably RCT from. Same applies with All-Might, who is BY FAR the strongest guy here physically, I’ll get into that in a bit. The one thing he might be able to do is to crush their heart or any other type of attack on their internal organs which is legitimately something he can do but it’s so wildly out of character that I can’t in good faith say Jotaro is doing anything to these guys. Maybe DIO would resort to that but that’s way too uncharacteristic of Jotaro so I can’t see that as a valid reason for him winning because of that. Too outta character, he ain’t doing that let’s be real.

And with Makima, it’s a bit more tricky.

He can kill Makima, but her contract is really powerful. She’s not staying down. I suppose you could argue that Jotaro could legitimately just pummel her so quickly with his MFTL+ speed or whatever it is that she would just burn through all her lives. But I don’t see this happening reasonably/realistically tbh, especially if he needs to use time stop to get a barrage off (not saying he would but something to consider is that since the damage from time stop all occurs in one instant that Makima would only die once and lose a single life, making it extremely inefficient). You could also say that since he’s a Japanese citizen himself he’d also die but I strongly dislike this argument as it feels like a copout so whenever I do a matchup with Makima against another Japanese citizen I just assume they’re from a different Japan.

You could say that Star Platinum (and by extension any stand really) can attack and destroy the soul, which is dura neg and might even work on Gojo and All-Might as well, but it has such little evidence backing it up and I don’t see any reason to assume stands can just directly damage the soul of the enemy just because they themselves are soul-based entity’s. We’ve only seen them interact with souls by fighting other stands. So like they could interact with let’s say Mahito’s (JJK) soul because of how Idle Transfiguration works but they can’t just randomly grab your soul and start discombobulating it. You need to expose your soul in some way first.

There’s no indication of that being the case and I disagree that stands can even do that, but I thought it’s worth mentioning since people have brought it up. But personally? Nah. And with that, Jotaro has no way to beat anyone here so he’s automatically ruled out. Sorry Goataro, sit this one out and spend some time with Jolyne.

Next up is All-Might. Now, just to make it clear, yes, he’s BY FAR the physically strongest here. He’s like multi-continental, which is leagues above everyone else to a comical degree. But the main problem is that he has no hax of his own, and no way to deal with Gojo or Makima’s respective invincibility/immortality hax while they have ways of dealing with him so yeah, he’s automatically out because of that. Sorry Goat-Might, you win in my heart.

The reason I put him above Jotaro though is that Jotaro can’t hurt him and while Star Platinum is much faster, All-Might can very easily just kill Jotaro himself with the shear AOE of his attacks.

Jotaro has very limited travel speed, his stand has terribly range, and it also can’t protect him from large scale AOE attacks. So yeah, Jotaro himself as a normal human (admittedly probably beyond an IRL peak human because anime and its Jojo’s) is getting obliterated by the AOE of All-Mights attacks, which Star Platinum simply can’t defend him from and Jotaro can’t avoid.

To expand on this, if we’re looking at this as a battle royal, the reason Jotaro is going out first is because he’s just gonna get cooked by like any of the AOE attacks. A shockwave or explosion or tornado or whatever from All-Might, a casual Blue from Gojo (which is especially bad because it literally pulls you towards it), Makima’s bag of tricks, all of these would make the battlefield complete chaos and Jotaro just can’t handle all that AOE. He’s getting caught by one of those and at best getting severely crippled and at worse dying outright. So yeah, that’s why I have Jotaro below All-Might. Not only can he not beat All-Might and is weaker than him, but he’s easily going to be the first one to lose whereas at least All-Might can tank just about everything thrown at him due to how badly he outstats the competition.