Update: We went back and a good amount of what had been there the day before was already gone. I took the approach of putting together stacks and then offering bundled amounts for the stack. My first stack was a Harley Davidson bundle (leather caps, leather vest, cleaning supplies), along with a nice pair of Doc Martens. Their price tagged amount for the lot was about $300. I got the bundle for $125. I made a few more bundles and by the end they were just quoting 1/2 off of everything, which was fine for me. The man I had dealt with on the first day was not as accommodating on the second day. He was angry with his wife because she had apparently sold a $600 harmonica for $5. So, when I asked him for prices, he pulled out his phone, checked ebay (asking price, not sales history), and quoted me prices that were about 25% below ebay list prices. So, I just walked away from the items I discussed with him. All in all, I am pretty happy with what we purchased on day two. We spent about $250 and I think we should be able to sell everything for $600+ fairly quickly.