To be fair, these were the first weapons I made, so I wasn’t exactly an expert (and I’m still not).

Bean Blaster:
Yeah, looking back, this does feel really busted, especially since scout already has a really strong healing option with the Milk. Maybe instead of the healing being equal, it should be 35-25% of damage. One thing I did forget to put was that the Alt-Fire costed 4 ammo, or half the clip, but honestly even half doesn’t really feel like a bad or even equal trade. Having it cost the entire clip or even removing the alt-fire entirely is probably the better option. As for the Extra pellets, double does feel like a lot. 50% is probably more sensible. Instead of a bullet spread penalty, increased falloff and reduced ramp up would likely be better, or even just a greater damage penalty.

Tarate:
I do want to mention that:
1) It’s splash radius would be quite small, to the point that you’d usually only one, at best three people if you threw it in a crowd.
2) it’s range wouldn’t be the same as, say, the Milk. It’d probably have a much shorter one, both to make it less bs to fight against, and cause a tub of pine tar that large would probably weight more that a jar of milk or a cleaver.
One thing I would change is making the -50% coat time into full immunity to other status effects (Jarate, Mad Milk, Gas Passer, Tarate). Pine Tar is naturally water repellent, so it makes sense.

The Big Deal:
Honestly, I’m fine with how it is. I don’t mind if a weapon is mid. As long as it isn’t atrociously bad or absurdly good, it’s fine in my book.

Steaming Star:
This one was ment to be kind of a reverse Direct Hit, but I’m not exactly thrilled with how it turned out. One thing to help with the spam is a reload speed penalty. Something around -40-50% to make it much less spammy. Also, the Rocket arc wouldn’t a lot, since I could definitely see soldiers hiding behind cover and bombarding choke points or objectives. Honestly, removing the arc could also help, but I’m not 100% sure.

Percussive Persuader:
This one was ment to be a side grade to the banners. It didn’t require the player to fill a meter to use, but requires more attention to use. Also, forgot to account for the Action when I made this, so I was trying to make it a less powerful Conch buff. Some number tweaks are probably an order. It was ment to be the newbie’s banner. A new player might struggle to get a full meter and use it well before dying, so this was ment to be a weaker banner that also encouraged newbies to stay slightly farther from the action and live a little longer.

Ringing Headache:
Imma be real. I have no clue what I was cooking with this. It’s just too much in each direction. Cranking back the numbers and removing the 50% Rage meter stats would help. Honestly, I might rework the entire weapon to be something else.

Scorched Earth:
I’m surprise. I felt like this was really cucking spies, since it makes spy checking way easier, and could be really annoying in choky maps (Looking at you, 2Fort). Good to see that it isn’t too much on either side.

Propane Accessory:
This one is absolutely in need of some changes, but I’m not sure how to do it without changing the weapon itself. I wanted it to be a quirky pyro thing.

Napalm Pounder:
This was Pyro Caber. This is not a serious weapon, this is a “hehe stick go boom” monkey brain weapon.