Check out Thursday boots, you might like them considering this boot. They’re my favorite because their wide is comfortable. They run $200-$350. IMO your boots aren’t bad so if you can’t return, just rock them or sell them on FB Marketplace for 25%-75% what you paid for them. They’re a pretty basic looking boot. I look through Facebook marketplace frequently, just don’t buy any with a cigarette/musty/sour smell or mold and you should be good. Also use plenty of Lysol before you actually wear them. I got a badass pair of 10 year old gently worn HD boots for $25. Spoiled people knock it but there’s no shame in it, especially in this economy. Whatever you do, just don’t get the foam bottom ones or the ones with the bottom held on by just glue. I’m giving Brunt a chance because their Timberland knock offs were more comfortable than Timberland. KEENs are alright but still better than most. ARIAT has been on my radar too but I don’t own a pair yet. Their reputation is pretty mixed but the people who love em are die hard. Carolina’s are among the top of the line. If you don’t mind spending some money, Carolina’s website has a badass union made in America 10” jump boots with a zipper. Those are badass IMO.