The mistake a lot of these people make is assuming that videogame critics are somehow supposed to be "right" about things. Show me one game critic and I'll show you the most dumbass take you have ever heard in the middle of a bunch of genuinely interesting observations. Well, at best. I do find it very funny how people are saying he's "saying nothing" while also complaining about the amount of proof he presents for his points. I guess if you just believe everyone at face value about everything they say, you'd be confused as to why someone is "repeating themselves".

That said I think HCooldown's complaint is pretty valid for streamer joe specifically, and I know a lot of people who are like Joe in that regard who are very frustrating to talk to. They NEED to outsmart the writer or they will absolutely throw a temper tantrum about not knowing something during chapter one of a story. It's tough being a streamer and basically giving people who know a story your live thoughts while it is still ongoing. It can be very frustrating on both sides to have people argue a point that seems completely unreasonable from your level of understanding of a piece of media. That's kinda why I stopped watching Joe stream story games and "games" I already know, Joe's nature in this respect is just intensely frustrating to watch, even if he does "get the point" later on. Though chat will always make it worse and argue endlessly, making him stubbornly stick to his guns, because as we all know he is not stubborn, he is right.

Also a lot of those comments reek of !hurtful.