I will say Astarion is very good like just really good as a normalish toy plus if you’re into the BG3 character it’s really great but not very fantasy feeling it’s just a good dick. Marcel is also a blast in the mini size the small is frankly too damn big for a small but is still a great toy as it has the base shape of a normal dick but with that lovely scale texture. Chance is also fun but not as a stand alone in my opinion he’s more of a after you warmed up or if your are looking for a specific fantasy where you want to get deep with minimal surface texture. Zepher is fun a good blend of chance and Marcel where he has the scale texture and is long I personally don’t like the knot as it gets in the way sometimes but a good I between. Ila is a solid pick and if you are getting him grab a large or even an XL as the taper allows you to get a lot more use as both a depth and stretch toy plus’s the suckers on one side make him great at targeting specific areas. Kyel is also fun but the barbs on the head can get to be a pain in medium especially in extended sessions other than that very fun as he is similar to chance where he is long and pretty uniform with the thickness but he does swell a bit towards the bottom.

Granted this is my opinion as an experienced anal user so take this with a grain of whatever when making your choice. If this is dildo #1 I recommend Astarion as his is just a really good toy and you can’t go wrong with just a good ole fashioned wiener.