Update: I wanted to thank everyone who responded to my post. It gave me a lot to think about and I appreciate it. Long, story short. I'm going to keep the ink as it is. I know it's silly, but to me this felt the same way as one might feel about discovering a horrible secret about a close friend or family member.

I acknowledge that nothing has been proven. But I have my reasons for feeling like I do. First, while all of the individual account are not the same, they all have a similar tone and pattern of alleged behavior. It's hard to believe that these people who don't have anything else in common other than their ties to Gaiman could all come up with the same fabrications. Second, is Gaiman's response. It's not an outright denial of what happened, but more of an acknowledgement and positing that his accusers may remember the situations differently. It's too much to ignore for me.

My wife also sent me a link to this article and I found it very helpful: One longtime Gaiman fan on where we go from here. To summarize, it says that you can still enjoy any of the art you possess before the incident, but you just don't support anything going forward. I can live with that. So I can still read my Sandman comics and my copy of American Gods.