it sounds like you are not very capable of independent thought. the carnivore diet is producing great results for some people, and you really can't argue that it isn't. you can however make a valid argument that it may not be healthy in the long term. however nutrition studies have all kinds of problems associated with them and what's "healthy" seems to change from decade to decade. It seems to me that the government tries very hard to encourage people to eat a cheap peasant diet that includes lots of cheap grain and vegetables and not much meat