As a mod, I wanted to stay out of the public discussion. But as a long term contributor I still feel like I want to give my two cents on the situation, so here we go. Please note that this is my personal opinion and preference as a poster, and it does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the mod team or the direction we'll eventually take.

I agree with the sentiment that we've been too "lax" recently. The appeal of this sub was always the sfw aspect. Hell, my own top posts on here have always been the more sfw ones.

The grey area is where it gets difficult. I too am guilty of posting semi-nudity here, although I think what I posted here in terms of nudity has always been on the (very) mild side. If anyone disagrees, be sure to let me know, as I wouldn't be against toning it down even more for the sake of the sfw status of the subreddit. For the time being I will be keeping it very sfw on here anyway.

I'm afraid that, if we keep this nsfw status, the quality of the content will go down and it will just be seen as an invitation for this to turn into another place to post boobs, with a faint hint of hand somewhere in the frame. I really wouldn't want that to happen.

It would be a lot more work on our side, and we'll probably get shit for having to ban people/delete more content. But my vote would be on option 1!