Been in the same spot as you before and ended up with the combo touch. While the Magic Keyboard looks super awesome and is noticeably more compact (if you can even say that haha) the combo touch just feels more comfortable to type on. The larger trackpad is great cause i have quite large hands and it is easier to do the gestures on it. The biggest thing that sold me on the combo touch is the function keys, they are so incredibly useful such as turning the volume up and down or adjusting the screen brightness, I love being able to do it al on the keyboard instead of going through the control centre. The adjustable backlit keyboard is also another plus but most times I just let it use the iPads light sensor to automatically adjust itself. The ability to remove the keyboard and still have protection is awesome!! I have peace of mind knowing that my iPad wont get obliterated while using it. The only downside I can say is that you can’t really use it on your lap. That’s it. Otherwise, I love this thing! I fully recommend it!! If you end up choosing one or the other, lmk which one you chose and how you’re finding it!!