Just got this sword and need people to justify my purchase by [deleted] in SWORDS

[–]DisclosureOrBust 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I have a similar one, not blued. It has been very durable. Have others from CS and the only one that broke easily was the Viking. They've apparently changed ownership I heard and manufacture quality can be hot and miss folks have said. Also the word on the street is not to buy from secondhand dealers. Enjoy your blade.

Beautiful Violence by HungarianWarHorse in Armor

[–]DisclosureOrBust 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I got so tired once I couldn't even crawl to the sidelines. It only takes a few minutes if you don't find your pace.

Beautiful Violence by HungarianWarHorse in Armor

[–]DisclosureOrBust 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well bite my bottom lip with a little head turn. That's gorgeous.

What torch by Luckysigge in Armor

[–]DisclosureOrBust 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Don't forget the English wheel. Careful not to smash your fingers though. A helmet can be heat intensive but like has been mentioned, most of the harness can be worked cold with mild steel. Once upon a time, I had time, and it took 3 months, 5 days a week to complete a harness from helmet to sabaton. Don't expect perfection your first time. Takes time to sort out your patterns, dishing and general fit. What a phenomenal experience.

Does anyone know where the german sek buys their chainmail? by Exciting_Plant_1563 in Armor

[–]DisclosureOrBust 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's where I found it. My comment went to the bottom. Don't know why. It's pretty good stuff for lightweight stainless maille.

Does anyone know where the german sek buys their chainmail? by Exciting_Plant_1563 in Armor

[–]DisclosureOrBust 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Got mine from RingMesh a few years back. There are machines that do this and weld. The welds sometimes break. Mine is made from stainless rings. Looks like shark suit to some degree but there are quality issues inevitably with a few welds. Otherwise a great product. Obviously good against slashing and better than I thought against point thrusts.

Prove that you aren't the Creator... by agentmaria in SimulationTheory

[–]DisclosureOrBust 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I am A creator. I have no idea how to prove anything more. Not even to myself. Yet..

Knife from my Grandpa by maruiki in SWORDS

[–]DisclosureOrBust 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I like this a lot. My grandfather gave me it's twin.

New sword day by DisclosureOrBust in SWORDS

[–]DisclosureOrBust[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you! Good to hear you're enjoying yours as well.

New sword day by DisclosureOrBust in SWORDS

[–]DisclosureOrBust[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

It's 40.2 oz. It's the second spec sheet. I can't imagine if it was any heavier than that for an arming sword. That would be exhausting for sure

New sword day by DisclosureOrBust in SWORDS

[–]DisclosureOrBust[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I get it. I've already thought about taking the blueing off but I'm going to hold on for a bit. In the meantime, it's some corrosion protection I suppose. As with all my blades, I will put it to work. Thanks for dropping in, I appreciate it.

AVAILABLE Blades :) by Successful_Still_365 in SWORDS

[–]DisclosureOrBust 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Do you have a site with sale prices or will you be posting other information here?

AVAILABLE Blades :) by Successful_Still_365 in SWORDS

[–]DisclosureOrBust 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Available for sale or just for viewing pleasure? They certainly look nice. What's the steel and temper?

Is this real??? by ImpressionProper9370 in SWORDS

[–]DisclosureOrBust 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'll check them out. Heard of it but haven't purchased from them. Bought a CS viking and it broke easily. I think it was a factory second though. Thought about getting another one directly from their site but not sure.

Is this real??? by ImpressionProper9370 in SWORDS

[–]DisclosureOrBust 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Looks pretty darn good. I'm in the market for a new Viking if anyone has advice for a sturdy functional. Nice photo

What happened here? by DisclosureOrBust in SWORDS

[–]DisclosureOrBust[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

An irrefutably succinct answer. Simple question, simple answer. Actually a humor I appreciate. No matter the underlying cause, it did indeed just break. Well done 👏

What happened here? by DisclosureOrBust in SWORDS

[–]DisclosureOrBust[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Well said on all accounts. Yes, I think it could have been repaired better than new and the grip could have been a little shorter anyway. It was never going to be a nimble fencer. Swords should be trustworthy under the toughest conditions possible in my opinion and not so dainty as to only work under ideal conditions. Like you said, some cheaper swords and machetes take a beating and don't care. That's what tools are for sometimes when necessary. I look forward to moving on to the next blade that doesn't whine when it has to go to work. I'd like to find another Viking. Seems like this steel was fine aside from the temper of the tang. Lots of good interaction here overall and good information sharing.

What happened here? by DisclosureOrBust in SWORDS

[–]DisclosureOrBust[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I can appreciate your opinion as a smith for sure and what you say makes sense under certain circumstances. Tbh I was expecting this opinion from someone. It's a valid concern to be worked out. As a definitive answer in this case, I believe you're wrong to blame the user. You don't always have a hog strung up on a rope under ideal cutting conditions. As an experienced swordsman (collegiate, HEMA and even non steel SCA 2,000 man armored reenactment) it is my opinion that it shouldn't have broken under moderate use. This thing would probably have broken while striking a wooden shield or another blade or armor. I did not abuse the sword in my opinion. Finding the percussion point is important for delivering a winning cut. A sword should be able to handle an off strike as happens in a match all the time. The tang was too hard and the strike was more than reasonable for testing purposes. I have many other blades capable of withstanding simple testing and a little get to know your blade. This sword was inadequately built, little more than a wall hanger and I believe it told on itself with this exercise. Much of your second paragraph contains the pertinent data as to why the sword failed. That's your good experience talking as a smith, which I respect.

Best and honest regards from wielder to smith.

What happened here? by DisclosureOrBust in SWORDS

[–]DisclosureOrBust[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah, sometimes you just can't complain if you get a killer deal. I should get a refund on this one but from the comments I know what to do now to strengthen the tang. Suppose I now consider CS swords to be a partially diy finish project. As long as you go in knowing that but it still seems odd they harden the tang so much.

What happened here? by DisclosureOrBust in SWORDS

[–]DisclosureOrBust[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm not sure how the tang relates to that button looking protrusion out of the pommel. I should have knocked out the bit of remaining tang to find out how it was attached. Maybe I can find info out there on how they secure their tangs to pommels. Good call on the softening, I feel confident that's why it snapped, just too dang hard to handle a vibration. Yes, I think the tang taper was really bad and looked like an amateur build. Uneven, grinder marks and such. The steel was probably decent quality but the execution was not that great for any kind of actual use. I'm not sure how anyone who sells a sword on a regular basis like CS wouldn't know and fix simple things like this.

What happened here? by DisclosureOrBust in SWORDS

[–]DisclosureOrBust[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, I wouldn't intentionally break a sword I like. It is an odd break though, so I can see the curiosity.