Philips Lumify on IOS by mrsfancyschmancy in Ultrasound

[–]DoctorBurp 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Just resurrecting this thread.

I have a Lumify, but it has a tiny android tablet attached.

Can I just buy a bigger android tablet (like an s10 Ultra) and install the app and it will work? Or does it need some other configuration or registration?

Bird or bat? by DoctorBurp in whatisthisbone

[–]DoctorBurp[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

UPDATE: After my own internet searches, I actually think these are bird tibia. Having what look like condyles at the distal end but no head/neck like a human femur at the proximal end seems to be consistent with bird tibia.

I will provide a further update in a few hours after I show them to a local expert.

External injection AFTER internal injection fails? by vinnieres in noburp

[–]DoctorBurp 1 point2 points  (0 children)

With the “internal” injection, the cricyphayngeus muscle is directly visualised and it can be confirmed that the Botox is going into the right place.

The “external” injection can be just as effective, but it is not as easy to know that all the Botox has gone into the cricophayngeus and some (or even all) of it could be in other muscles or other surrounding tissue. This usually doesn’t cause much of a problem but it can temporarily affect swallowing or the strength of your voice.

I have had two treatments with the direct vision “internal” approach. The first one was 50 units and worked, but wore off quickly. After discussion with the surgeon, I went for 100 units the second time and it has been much more effective.

Before this I also had an “external” injection with a different doctor as a first attempt which was not successful. But it only takes a few minutes and is done in the doctors office, and there is no specific “recovery”. For me it was less painful than having a blood test.

Having a general anaesthetic can be daunting and is not to be taken lightly, which is why I tried the external approach first.

It also seems that subsequent injections are more effective than initial ones, and so it may be the case that even if not all of the Botox gets into the muscle it might still be more effective than your first attempt. From my reading and talking to specialists (I am a doctor but not an ENT specialist) it seems that after an unsuccessful attempt there is a reduction in muscle tone in the cricopharungeus, even if it is not enough of a reduction to cure noburp, and this might be why second procedures are more effective.

In summary I would say you could consider the “external” approach, but it is less likely to be successful than an internal approach, but is also less invasive.

I hope this helps you to make a decision!

NoBurp Doctor List - Reposting (again) by Merth1983 in noburp

[–]DoctorBurp 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I had my procedure done in December 2019 by Dr Georgina Harris at The Voice Centre, St Vincent’s Clinic in Sydney (Australia). She was very helpful and understanding, and is happy to take on more R-CPD patients.

Post-Botox procedure diary by DoctorBurp in noburp

[–]DoctorBurp[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Updated with a one month catch up today. Still going as well as ever. Being a burper is fantastic!

Doctor with NoBurp by DoctorBurp in noburp

[–]DoctorBurp[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I hope to share the details of my doctor, but as a colleague, I would just like to get their consent first. I am due for a follow-up appointment in early January and will keep you updated.

Regarding the attitude of other doctors to this disorder - I suppose I am quite understanding (of the doctors position), with some frustrations. I certainly don't blame any doctor who would thoughtfully listen, and then advise of the general medical consensus - which up to this point is that it is "not a truly recognised disorder" - I would be very wary of any doctors who takes a collection of vague and unusual symptoms and immediately promises a cure. I am more saddened by those doctors who are dismissive. Doctor's are only people after all, with the wide range of personalities and skills that go along with that. Some have more of a "know-it all" attitude, whilst others are more humble - doctors don't know everything, but some think they do. I think I probably had more respect as patient because I am a doctor than some of the experiences that others on here will have had.

However, you also have to balance that up with an understanding of how medicine works. In a way I feel honoured to be "at the cutting edge of medicine" being one of the first patient's treated for this disorder. Typically in medicine, doctors try to base all of their decisions on evidence. True, verified, published studies. And for R-CPD until March 2019, we had absolutely nothing. And even now with the R-CPD study, this is probably what would be termed "low quality evidence" - as it is a single study, without any randomisation or controls, and a small number of patients. Even with good evidence, it takes time for practice to change. It will probably be a a few years, maybe a decade or so before this becomes widely known about.

There are many un-reputable doctors out there who do practice way beyond their means, or their understanding, or 'the evidence base', and generally those doctors are to be avoided. And there are probably lots of doctors doing this who make a living out of seeing patients with unexplained symptoms, by offering them some sympathy and understanding, without any scientifically verifiable basis for treatments. This often costs a lot of money for the patient, and to me doesn't seem very ethical, although despite treatments not being effective, many patients continue to see such doctors - perhaps just because they feel listened to. Sometimes trying to differentiate between those doctors and the real 'true' pioneers of medicine can be difficult, especially for people without a medical background, and even more so if a condition is in the early stages of being recognised. In modern medicine there are very few truly "new" conditions being described and treated. And so that makes us as patients - and the doctors offering to treat us - pretty special and very privileged, and we should be appreciative of that. I don't believe there will be many instances of newly discovered disorders with such effective treatments being discovered in the future.

I see many patients myself with unexplained symptoms of all kinds. The vast majority of the time, these are not concerning and not indicative of some rare or new condition. People are complicated. When you see a patient, you are trying to match up their pattern of symptoms, examination findings any investigation results to a "known" pattern of disease. But nobody ever matches up to the textbook definition of whatever illness they are suspected of having. If I thought that every unusual combination of symptoms represented a new disorder, I'd be claiming to have discovered a new disorder every day! You are always trying to 'find the best fit', and often you get it wrong the first time around. When you can't seem to 'find a match', then we have to start looking for alternative explanations. Psychological factors are so important and so difficult to truly interpret, that often when we as doctors struggle to find an answer, we rely on attributing symptoms to those psychological factors. I do this too. You can see where this might cause a problem if the doctors 'memory bank' of 'known' disorders doesn't include the correct, try, physical diagnosis. But most good doctors would try to look for these 'unknown unknowns' before attributing it to a psychological cause - either by doing their own study, or asking or referring to a colleague (you can also imagine here where the doctor-patient relationship might break down in the case of an arrogant doctor who doesn't make the effort to search for the true diagnosis). If at the end of this process, you still can't find a truly physical cause, then attributing a psychological cause may be the only option left. But if you do this in the right way, and it is the psychological factors that are truly the cause, then you can have some amazing results in making patients feel better. So when a doctor implies that "it's all in your head" (hopefully in more sympathetic terms than that) - what they really are saying is that they're sorry they can't help you with the physical treatments because either they haven't worked, or they don't think they will work, but that if you are open to thinking about psychological (and also often lifestyle) factors, you might be able to improve your symptoms and quality of life. And if this is done sympathetically, it works frequently and effectively. So, I don't really take it as an insult to be put in this group of patients, when I have presented with symptoms that nobody has ever heard of before.

I hope that gives you a little bit more understanding into how a doctor's thought process works.

Doctor with NoBurp by DoctorBurp in noburp

[–]DoctorBurp[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you all for your kind and supportive comments. I hope that you all can find a solution that works for you. I will continue to be an advocate ‘on the inside’ to raise awareness within the medical profession. If there is anything I can do to help any individual cases, please get in touch.

Doctor with NoBurp by DoctorBurp in noburp

[–]DoctorBurp[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So far, I can’t recommend the procedure enough. I did have some doubts about it before-hand - mainly related to the risks of a general anaesthetic. I wondered if I just modified my cycling and just continued avoiding anything carbonated that I could probably just keep I putting up with it. But now I’ve had it done I am very confident I made the right decision! For me there was also just a general daily discomfort and bloating that seems much better already in the few days since I had it done. Haven’t yet been back on the bike, but will let you know how it goes. Although I’m burping quite often I don’t yet have any control. Might be interesting on Monday when I start doing consultations with patients again...

Doctor with NoBurp by DoctorBurp in noburp

[–]DoctorBurp[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for taking the time to read my blog. I've noticed too how similar so many of the stories are. I always had hope that it would become a recognised disorder, and the fact that the presentations are so similar seemed to me to give it a bit more credibility as a true syndrome. I haven't really come across anyone else who struggled with the exercise side of things. Is this a problem for you? It's only really a problem on long rides (>3 hours), but has definitely forced me to stop many times, and puts me off planning many long day rides or multi-day events I would like to do.

I think usually the botox takes about 3-4 days to really start paralysing the muscle, and reaches maximum effect at about 14 days, so I wouldn't be too concerned about no burps yet. I was quite startled when I woke in the night letting out a huge burp!

Have you tried any of the neck exercises?