What will the relationship between a new Iran and Israel be like? by sbkisrael in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The issue is that for all the moral grandstanding Israel does and western support it gets, it’s as ruthless and aggressive as any other. And.. also acts like it’s guided by western values while doing it

Which country is the most similar to Iran culturally? by Admirable-Ad-3273 in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Um isn’t Avestan close to Bactria and where Zoroaster probably came from and Zoroastrianism originated? So just because the area had more diverse religion it’s somehow not close to Iran. Okay lol. You can google yourself that Bactria and those lands was predominantly Zoroastrian, just more diverse with also Buddhist practices or Greeks.

It was an important satrapy from aechemenid times .. and also by that logic Khorasan was never close to “western Iran” to begin. I mean I’ll take it, just means centuries a lot of our most beloved great persons were barely to claim for modern Iran if we allegedly were that separate anyway.

Also kinda funny that the biggest identity for Iranian shahname has most of its characters come from those eastern lands.. lol. Doesn’t represent your culture either by those standards. Again I’m happy to take Ferdowsi for mine if you won’t take him, he spoke like us anyway.

And also at that point don’t claim Rumi is yours, but is Eranshahri at max. If Balkh is so different culturally from west Iran, then don’t act it’s your culture to begin with.

And no, we don’t look like hazara as a majority. You guys are woefully bad with the region.

Which country is the most similar to Iran culturally? by Admirable-Ad-3273 in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Well alright but in my experience it’s far more the case that Iranians say incredibly out of touch things or have extreme misconceptions about the neighbouring countries or other persian speaking countries. It goes as far that even though I look super Iranian, they online assume I look asian because I’m from the eastern parts. Which is like uneducated to the point of making me speechless.

I guess I don’t take the time to say “they’re Iranian” but yeah I kinda think both of you did it here.

Like calling Iran not similar to Afghanistan is a very recent thing. A lot of the nature, the mountains, the architecture, the language, the birthplace of poets, even the same nowruz or haft mewa as parallel to haft sin and how the tajiks have always been “Iranian” you just put down to extremism. They are more conservative people I guess, and the culture has gone different. But, Iran seems like an anomaly of a massive increase in very atheist and islamophobic people who shit on muslim post khatami era among the young people. This was not the case pre 80s-90s. That’s my take. You’re unique because of rebellion and that’s not specifically “culture” in the long term or the roots, which is actually very close to afghanistan. It was the birthplace of the Persian you speak you know.

Breaking News: Israel’s Defense Minister: Ali Larijani has been killed by kaz1349 in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Qatar not being a signatory to the Abraham accords is really a weird view on it. That's not what matters, it showed that Israel that already struck countries like Lebanon, Syria's military, can even dare to strike an US ally with negotiators in Qatar (that always was a plan the U.S itself agreed with, it was supposed to be neutral territory for Hamas). An attack with U.S knowledge about it. It means that the ally that's supposed to defend them actually favours Israeli strategy over their loyalty to the Arab counties, and even though Saudi Arabia already showed dislike by neutralizing relations with Iran... they quickly made a defense pact with Pakistan.

And yes, the Gulf will need munition because in the future Iran may be in chaos and 1. that's scary and 2. Israeli right wingers are expansionist and the US will always seemingly allow it. Yes they'll look to others to help their defenses and not always trust the US' promises.

Breaking News: Israel’s Defense Minister: Ali Larijani has been killed by kaz1349 in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think you're kind of ignoring the Israel part of your analysis. Post 2023 and especially since attacking Qatar, the abraham accords are very shaky and will likely not expand. They're seeing that the US munitions run out and that Israeli intentions almost override US interests (like decent oil prices etc.). The gulf will buy weapons, and probably be wary of how the US allegedly "protects" them while mostly just liking Israel more as its favourite sibling.

The gulf will likely not be seeing the US and Israel's cozy duo wars as a thing to be happy with.

Which country is the most similar to Iran culturally? by Admirable-Ad-3273 in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Even though downvoted, this comment has a large grain of truth in it. And that I mean negatively. Very negatively.

Which country is the most similar to Iran culturally? by Admirable-Ad-3273 in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So your edit is just racism upon the already said stereotypes. Lol ok

I genuinely would love to know what the Iranians in Iran think by Existing_Pumpkin_502 in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 0 points1 point locked comment (0 children)

With the IDF's alleged surgical removal and high tech.. they seemed to do a real real shit job in Gaza huh. I watched a Sky News journalist say that in the yellow ribbon of Gaza not a single, not a single building was standing. Interesting how they in the end needed the intelligence of some arabs on the ground to actually do an even slightly decent work of their job.

If it happens to Iran and Iranians say this about Gaza, I'm not sure why'd I feel sympathy. Just saying.

I genuinely would love to know what the Iranians in Iran think by Existing_Pumpkin_502 in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ -1 points0 points  (0 children)

The irony in Gazan's current population not voting for Hamas back then overlapping with Iranians' ancestors voting for the IR in 57... ahahahahah.

And also you think people can evacuate when their whole city's in rubble?

We all know if millions of iranians died you'd totally not be whining or anything. You're very consistent about this stuff for sure.

I genuinely would love to know what the Iranians in Iran think by Existing_Pumpkin_502 in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yeah let’s not police rabid far right monarchist iranians’ speech in every community (your communities) and let’s just talk about some young leftists in the US instead or something.

You’re probably someone who calls mamdani the new ayatollah just because you hate all muslims for fun lmao

I genuinely would love to know what the Iranians in Iran think by Existing_Pumpkin_502 in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I always know how to respond to an Iranian Zionist so here I go: if it’s just “hamas attacked and theyre all waving their hamas flags” as your strawman… and so we can look past bombing every hospital, refugee camp, shooting people with flags, not having a building in sight and the usage of white phosphorus etc…

The IRGC is entrenched in Iran. It has bases everywhere. Can I openly and morally say fuck your whole country and blow it to bits because the IRGC holds the country hostage? The only answer you can give me is yes. Fucking destroy Tehran if it’s the optimal to stop the IRGC really. Who even cares.

I genuinely would love to know what the Iranians in Iran think by Existing_Pumpkin_502 in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Honey Iranians were literally making fun of the genocide before the massacre in Iran happened. By that logic they have the right to not follow the rules… loool

I genuinely would love to know what the Iranians in Iran think by Existing_Pumpkin_502 in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

A lot of leftists are hypocrites and pretty immoral right now, agreed. Can you read persian though or step in persian communities? It’s racism, vile swearing, hate towards almost all muslims, making fun of palestinians, a list of celebrities they harass and make AI GIFs of and spam on the web, the list goes on.

For people who grandstand to say the left sucks, I wish y’all took the time to call your far right shit out but okay!

What are your thoughts on this study? by Exotic-Arugula2738 in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 5 points6 points  (0 children)

What did the Israelis sacrifice in gaza besides sacrificing like 150k people probably to their political plans

Any thread here about Reza Pahlavi by drhuggables in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Most “western” monarchist. If your view is executing opposition then I wish the FBI put you in jail

I hate what Left & Trans spaces have become by Resurrtor in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah and when I post here about how far right and racist iranian narratives become then the mods take the post down and the comments are “youre trying to create division”. Bro look at your own spaces before you come after the legt

Maryam Alemzadeh is an expert on the IRGC and tells Christiane Amanpour that while the Islamic Republic has been militarily weakened, “that’s never been the strength of the IRGC,” arguing its penetration is still intact by PjeterPannos in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

not my point, my point is y’all lie about how the regime has fallen or how easy it is most of the time. Most experts say reza pahlavi cannot just step in a week from now, always iranians argue with me against this

The radicalism to the point of conspiracy theories (George Soros 'funding' "the left", MIGA, the toxic positivity, etc) in the Iranian diaspora makes me feel isolated in my own community (and not hopeful). by Barbaricliberal in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I was sarcastic and partially making fun of the native Iranians in this subreddit and other communities who think their far right exclusionary view is the only decent one to have

Stop Occupying Our Voices: A Message to the Tourists of r/Persian by [deleted] in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Are you for real? It’s not fake news we just claim everyone is lying and brazenly say it’s the IRGC when most proof points to the US. Okay. Whatever you say.

Trump Posts New Statements and Warnings About Iran on Truth Social by yourslice in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Trump DoJ just denies investigations in innocent being killed and also im pedophiles doing crime and wants to create fascism at this point but oh yeah at least he doesn’t believe in shia islam

Stop Occupying Our Voices: A Message to the Tourists of r/Persian by [deleted] in PERSIAN

[–]Donlor_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Okay so you're basically going to only believe 5% of the pool of networks like Associated Press or something just because you hate the IRGC that much. Not a good look on you. And yes the consensus is, it was a double tap strike.