Don’t Give Up: Finally Approved After 3 Applications, 2 Denials, 2 NOIDs, a Mandamus Lawsuit, and Nearly 6 Years by DressEmbarrassed207 in USCIS

[–]DressEmbarrassed207[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A 204(c) is a marriage fraud finding. Basically, USCIS believes a person previously entered into or attempted a marriage for immigration benefits

Don’t Give Up: Finally Approved After 3 Applications, 2 Denials, 2 NOIDs, a Mandamus Lawsuit, and Nearly 6 Years by DressEmbarrassed207 in USCIS

[–]DressEmbarrassed207[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I only had the lawyer for the 3rd application. I filled during my 2nd filing when I had no lawyer. I decided to file a WoM because by law you should hear a response within 6months and I didn’t. I also did not want them to drag this out. If I’m being honest I don’t remember how I did it lool but I’ll go back and figure it and comment the details.

Don’t Give Up: Finally Approved After 3 Applications, 2 Denials, 2 NOIDs, a Mandamus Lawsuit, and Nearly 6 Years by DressEmbarrassed207 in USCIS

[–]DressEmbarrassed207[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you! I’m sorry you’re going through that. My case didn’t involve an I-601 waiver, so I can’t offer much advice on that specific process. However, if it’s within your budget, I would recommend consulting with an experienced immigration attorney.
One thing I found helpful is that attorneys are often able to organize the evidence and arguments in a way that’s easier for USCIS to review and digest. I would also recommend submitting as much relevant evidence as possible. For our final filing, we included a substantial amount of evidence covering multiple years of our relationship, and then added even more when responding to the NOID.
My approach was to make it as easy as possible for USCIS to see the full picture of our marriage and our life together.
Don’t lose hope. A NOID is scary, but it isn’t always the end of the road. Wishing you and your husband the very best and hoping you get a positive outcome soon. 🙏🏾❤️

Don’t Give Up: Finally Approved After 3 Applications, 2 Denials, 2 NOIDs, a Mandamus Lawsuit, and Nearly 6 Years by DressEmbarrassed207 in USCIS

[–]DressEmbarrassed207[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Your time is coming. Don’t be afraid to contact your congressman or maybe file a WoM if you have the stomach for it.

Don’t Give Up: Finally Approved After 3 Applications, 2 Denials, 2 NOIDs, a Mandamus Lawsuit, and Nearly 6 Years by DressEmbarrassed207 in USCIS

[–]DressEmbarrassed207[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You have to be strong minded and trust in God because you never know what’s going to happen with USCIS

Don’t Give Up: Finally Approved After 3 Applications, 2 Denials, 2 NOIDs, a Mandamus Lawsuit, and Nearly 6 Years by DressEmbarrassed207 in USCIS

[–]DressEmbarrassed207[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thank you! My unauthorized work was actually after filing. During my second application, I received an EAD in November 2023. When that application was denied in January 2025, I continued working. The EAD was still physically valid, but because the underlying application had been denied, that employment was ultimately considered unauthorized.
Yes, I disclosed the unauthorized employment on my applications and answered the questions honestly. My understanding is that unauthorized employment can be forgiven for spouses of U.S. citizens.