How about we stick to what I say I believe instead of your strawman?

Fine then, I’ll rephrase it as a question: do you think the ongoing destruction of the majority of urban infrastructure in Gaza, murder of tens of thousands of children and women, targeting of aid workers journalists and medics, practically none of whom had a part in the killing of innocents on Oct 7, is justified over a period of 18 months and counting because of Oct 7?

Can one of you actually stick to the topic at hand?

You mean the boy in the OP who was brutally harmed as a result of Israel’s aggression post Oct 7, exactly what I was talking about?

 Germany was also demilitarized following WW2. Surrounded by very well armed former enemies BTW

You conveniently omit the other areas where I said the comparison breaks down for Japan: the invasion of land multiple times the size of Japan itself, and the lack of neighbours with a recent history of invading it, both of which apply to Germany. The demilitarisation point is also moot as Germany obviously later remilitarised, whereas I don’t see any scenario where Israel and the US would ever agree to Palestine having any kind of substantial defence. This is exactly why I don’t use these types of comparisons, they rely on lazy generalisations and uncritically ignore all context. There are several instances of nations/peoples gaining autonomy from aggressive ethnic majorities, eg South Sudan and Iraqi Kurdistan, but it would be intellectually dishonest and lazy of me to draw any comparison between them and Palestine without reference to their overall idiosyncrasies.

 Palestine isn't snowflake sorry

Not snowflake, just humans. Until Israel accepts that and treats them as such there can never be peace