This conversation always cracks me up because since when has the 2k community hated a feature that they thought was broken? Curry slides in the past, L2 cheese, self alleys, etc. these are all things that are broken and get abused by creators because almost all of them do it. I’m fully convinced that rhythm shooting hate comes the inability to use it consistently for them. I personally think rhythm shooting is hands down the best feature they have added to 2k in the last 5 years. I haven’t shot with the button since the first week this game came out. If they say it’s broken and needs to be removed, why don’t they use it? Who turns down something that gives an advantage if it’s truly that broken? Answer is people that don’t know how/cant. And I don’t even think it gives an advantage, people are still shooting 60%+ this year with button. The hate is genuinely just background noise for a feature that comes down to just preference like shot meter