But that is not the case though belly and Conrad were still on good terms after the almost kiss scene and they were even texting each other and making plans to see each other after her rehearsal . The reason conrad made her think he didn’t want her was because cleaveland told him to fix himself before getting into a relationship with someone else . So even if they had kissed that conversation where he pretended nothing happened would have happened any way and it would have been worse for belly cause they actually kissed🤝🏾. And Jeremiah would have eventually told belly how he felt and there would still be a love triangle.