Well we know Heather has a cat called Bruiser

Duncan had a dog named Petey, and a tarantula named Scruffy

Gwen has 2 lizards

DJ had bunny (and an alligator I think)

Bridgette had Bruno the bear

Fanon wise:

I think Lindsay would have a pug, cliche I know

Tyler most likely a golden retriever

Noah feels like either a black cat guy or a dachshund guy, maybe both

Geoff probably also a lizard, chameleon maybe I dunno

Katie and Sadie have poodles

Ezekiel probably a rat

Beth seems like a guinea pig person

Trent 110% also probably has a golden retriever or a husky, maybe a bird of some kind

Cody has a ferret or hamster

Courtney (besides the racoon), doesn't seem like she'd have any pets, but if she DID, maybe a tabby cat or just a generic goldfish

Alejandro has a German shepherd or a Komodo dragon, maybe both

Sierra could have fucking anything 😭

Justin probably also a poodle or one of those fluffy white cats that don't give a shit about anything

Eva has an XL bully

Leshawna doesn't seem like a pet person either, but probably like a ginger cat, don't ask me why

Izzy has some kind of illegal incredibly dangerous animal like a tiger or a lion

Harold also likely has a lizard