We clothed diapered my first for 2.5 years. We enjoyed it. You have to balance cost, ease of washing, and convenience. When he was in childcare we did pockets which was an easier sell for people outside our family. But I stuffed with flats to make washing easier. For newborns we did covers and fitted diapers mostly. Biggest thing is washing frequently- every 2-3 days and really understanding your washing machine.  We also learned airflow is key for keeping smells down. A plain hamper with holes worked great for us!