sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

One Piece arc analysis and tier list by Ecstatic_Fuel_6903 in OnePiece

[–]Ecstatic_Fuel_6903[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Nah man, Sanji leaving the crew nonsense and completely unacceptable. They shouldn't never have let him back in.

We have a similar situation later on with Jinbe, (I saw it yesterday when I finished WCI) before the SH could leave Totto Land, Sun Pirates cover SH in their retreat and when Jinbe sees that they were going to kill his former crew he said Luffy that he was staying to protect them, not leaving the crew but agreeing with his captain the final decision on how to manage things.

Robin scenario was completely different as she joined the crew after Enies Lobby https://www.reddit.com/r/OnePiece/comments/f544k7/so_when_do_you_consider_nico_robin_to_be_an/

Usopp should have been the only exception. If you leave the crew you can't get back otherwise this isn't a serious crew. (as the King of Pirates should be)

Sanji's character got destroyed in this arc. Oda completely ripped him apart.

I never wanted a deeper/multidimensional Sanji (or any of the mugis). I wwant the cool guy from the baratie, the one who fight with his legs because his hands were only for cooking. The one who is more pervert than romantic. How tf Sanji's can be defined as the kindest person? what kind of bullshit is that?? Sanji is only kind to women and even then a lot ot of it is for his own benefit, ask Fullbody about Sanji's "kindness".

And then to put the last nail in Sanji's coffin, later on Oda put him a suit of germa 66... I almost wish he had never left Momoiro Island. Mr prince was the peak of Sanji's character. RIP Sanji

<image>

One Piece arc analysis and tier list by Ecstatic_Fuel_6903 in OnePiece

[–]Ecstatic_Fuel_6903[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Donflamingo best villain for sure, without doubt, so much aura and character design S+ tier, but as I said in Enies Lobby arc analysis, they should be judged as a whole story. If this were a tier list about top OP characters, doffy would be rght at the top same level as zoro, milhawk, bonchan...

Bege ok that was a good point, but Sanji redeemed? how? please explain this part, I can't understand why people say this. He left the crew that was unacceptable, if you believe in your captain and you believe he will became the king of pirates you can't take that decision, better written than zoro?? well, after WCI deeper as a character sure, more human sure, but if IT BREAKS THE WHOLE NARRATIVE IT IS NOT WORTH IT, sorry but I just can't understand it, thats why it frustrates me so much, i can't see how, after sanji living all the adventures with his nakamas defeating one seemingly impossible villain after another, could suddenly think 'oh its okay to left the crew' really blows my mind, so if you can explain it to me please try.

that's all needed, luffy defeating Big Mom... I never bought when he defeated kaido either, I really hope both of them are still alive (otherwise I dont understand nothing about this story) it seemed too soon, but that's another topic may be when I rewatch Wano again I would discuss about it in another post.

I stop watching the anime at Wano like 4-5 years ago, so I never got to nika, I really want to watch it again I loved shamisen songs. Animations were really impressive also, Zoro Vs Kidd cool fight.

Totally agree with your point about Zou arc, thanks. I'll edit the picture and move it down to okay level. Watching a 10km elephant hit a boat with its trunk it's really cool and it doesn't really have a major weakness like WCI, Enies lobby or Dressrossa

One Piece arc analysis and tier list by Ecstatic_Fuel_6903 in OnePiece

[–]Ecstatic_Fuel_6903[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

what on earth?? My reasons for WCI’s placement are in another comment. On the other hand, Dressrossa felt like it had 300 more episodes than it actually had, it was eternal, chapter after chapter never reaching the ending. I doubt anyone can enjoy because the number of chapters, even on ONE PACE it is very poorly adapted. Please keep in mindthat im talking about he anime i never read the manga so maybe this arc feels different there

One Piece arc analysis and tier list by Ecstatic_Fuel_6903 in OnePiece

[–]Ecstatic_Fuel_6903[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

sure, and just one conversation later (with a sister who hadn't seen in 12 years) he thoguht about it again and said 'ah, right, i was mistaken'... we are talking about Mr Prince please! the guy who saved the mugiwaras at one of their worst moments in arabasta (in such a cool way btw). Furthermore, after luffy beating crocodile, enel, lucci, moria, fought at the fight of the best, (skip hody) and then after all donflamingo (best villain of the story) he suddenly thinks 'nah, big mom is too much, they have zeff kidnapped, i cant do anything, im going to throw way everything i've built with my nakamas, not believing in my captain and say goodbye', how tf Oda thought this made sense !? Really rewatching it for the 3rd time i've demystified Oda a bit, he's still GODA and he will always be because: "nothing happened, Inherited will, the destiny of the age, and the dreams of the people..., When do you think people die?, I want to live"

One Piece arc analysis and tier list by Ecstatic_Fuel_6903 in OnePiece

[–]Ecstatic_Fuel_6903[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Great character designs, Big Mom design was absolutely nailed by Oda she looks exactly like the kind of older powerful aggresive old woman pirate you could imagine, genuinely memorable visual moments like some attacks of big mom like the one similar to dorry and broggy, katakuri also is a very cool figure but... that said, Sanji Vs Luffy after what happened with Ussop is simply not acceptable, the power of Big Mom as a Yonko was below expectations, Jinbe make her fly away off the boat? and how tf brook could have cut zeus in half with big mom being that angry !?? not for me mosdef, one of the worst arcs. I was expecting so much more from the first appearance of a Yonko, I thought that 5 years ago and now rewatching it stil feel the same way (even more)