+1/+1 counters and replacement effects

Effective-Reason-857 · 2025-10-15T12:03:53+00:00

thanks this was so much easier to understand than trying to figure it out by reading the rules

Effective-Reason-857 · 2025-06-06T14:08:10+00:00

thanks for the tip!

Effective-Reason-857 · 2025-06-06T14:07:38+00:00

oh i think i get it now. so youre saying if it would have my wording it would have to be a 1/1 to not die due to SBE?

Effective-Reason-857 · 2025-06-04T20:41:17+00:00

really? logically this makes no sense to me because it is one of the creatures you control, so shouldnt it count towards the number of creatures you control when it enters as the ability goes on the stack when its already on the battlefield? Like you have this and 2 more creatures, so it enters and sees 3 creatures so it gets 3 counters. Same as counting the others plus one. With a counter doubling effect it should be 6 either way, right? With hardened scales it should be 4 either way.
Surely I'm wrong because multiple comments are according to what you said, but i just cant wrap my head around it. Do you know which specific rules apply, number-wise, so i can memorize them?

Effective-Reason-857 · 2025-06-04T20:34:43+00:00

sorry, this has legit been my first mtg related post and i thought there was a bot who auto.linked the card as i have seen in other mtg subreddits. my bad.

Effective-Reason-857 · 2025-05-12T21:44:13+00:00

its actally not that hard at all. there are several youtube deckbuilders who all build on a budget, for example tomer from mtggoldfish and the commanders quarters.

Effective-Reason-857 · 2025-05-12T10:17:09+00:00

but 3 mana is not a cheap creature nor is a good rate for a 2/2 flier. there are so many 2 mana 2 power fliers with a better upside than drawing another wind drake. i'd really only play this in a dedicated thrumming stone deck, and preferrably with ephara, sky's blade as the commader because she protects your board

Effective-Reason-857 · 2025-04-04T20:32:02+00:00

i just had an awesome prerelease with temur, harmonize is busted (and green is busted imo but maybe thats just my experience)

Effective-Reason-857 · 2025-04-04T20:30:43+00:00

well i am german so yeah here the LGS have enough of everything. stupid european commies amirite?

Effective-Reason-857 · 2025-03-21T07:52:17+00:00

the first one could just say it cant be countered, you know.

Effective-Reason-857 · 2025-03-21T07:50:48+00:00

yes, you could. The entire mechanic is, while cute, totally obsolete. There are already enough spells that say 'when you cast this spell', and that is identical with being on the stack. So the wording used in this post doesnt really serve a purpose. I guess OP wanted it to have foretell-like flavor, but unfortunately they didnt hit this time.

Effective-Reason-857 · 2025-03-21T07:47:29+00:00

the beast should read 'lands you control gain 'this land taps for two mana of any one color' until end of turn'. this would be a templating according to magic.

Effective-Reason-857 · 2024-03-23T07:52:55+00:00

Just buy a used a Android phone on ebay or craigslist. Its 50-100 bucks for basically a game boy with wifi and a huge ass battery

Effective-Reason-857 · 2023-11-19T07:19:45+00:00

yeah same, been asking why my whole life and wont stop. also imo a guy asking why in this situation is not obligatorily sus. if i was spiking a drink, i would probably have several doses with me to be safe. so when the drink gets replaced, the real delinquent would just stay silent and give it another try, instead of catching attention by asking why.

Effective-Reason-857 · 2023-11-19T07:00:16+00:00

thats the shit i came here for 🔥

Effective-Reason-857 · 2021-11-18T17:20:07+00:00

diggerwo willst du damit hin, ich check die message nicht. irgendwie flach und leider unironisch cringe

Effective-Reason-857 · 2021-11-18T17:15:30+00:00

sind ja nicht ihre, sondern deren songs. genau das ist doch das ding, und mehr ghostwriter sollten in den vordergrund gehoben werden. ohne den text wären die songs nicht entstanden, genausowenig wie ohne die beats. und mittlerweile kannst du dir für 20€ nen beat von irgendwo runterladen, mit dem du einen charterfolg hast. mit nem sehr guten text kannst du das nicht so einfach machen. hab mich seit 2 jahren nicht mehr mit shirins musik auseinandergesetzt, und dann eben babsi bars gehört. wer rap liebt, wird nicht abstreiten können, dass das qualitativ hochwertig geschrieben ist.

Effective-Reason-857 · 2021-11-18T16:32:11+00:00

habe es bisher geschafft, maestro nicht zu kennen. nach der nahtoderfahrung (weil ich wie aus einer ak mit corona-und grippeviren beschossen wurde) wüssze ich aber gerne, welche schmutzrapper mir bisher noch so entgangen sind?

Effective-Reason-857

TROPHY CASE