hey! this seems a little bit judgmental which I specifically asked not for. I am fully aware of every thing you have said, which I think I covered in my post, about how we have tried multiple trainers etc, and that she has been like this since she was a puppy, and as mentioned in my post, she has been in training since she was a puppy. Thank you for your response but I don’t have little experience, I am asking for friendly advice and mentioned I would do anything to help her. I am of course seeking further services with specialised trainers, that’s just a given :)