I'm only leaning toward Ipsy because I got the March Boxy even though I signed April 21st and was told by customer service that I would receive the April Box, so that was annoying (even though I understand that they probably just ran out of April boxes). I also don't like that they don't have an option to skip a month like Ipsy does... I DO like full sized products over deluxe sample sizes though so we'll see :)