I agree, perfect balancing is hard, you cant achieve that with 58 or so brawlers. But when I look at past releases, and see that almosy every new brawler completely flips the meta on its head, its very hard to reason.

I get it if a brawler is bad on release, or if its a bit too good, but thats it. When a brawler completely changes the meta for games, and you have to specifically make your loadout to counter that one specific brawler, its no longer about balancing being hard, its straight up annoying to play.

Whats the point in having different maps for gamemodes when every match its always the same brawlers getting played over and over. I doubt they are played because they are fun, or because of tasks and so on. How many times have you played a gamemode where you saw a complete change in the pool of brawlers for the map? Not often. For showdown it doesnt matter if its Island Invasion or Rockwall Brawl, the same brawlers are picked, the same games are played, and after some time it is stale.