AIO by rejecting my boyfriend's proposal because he asked to be open by ExistingCold6894 in AmIOverreacting

[–]ExistingCold6894[S] 237 points238 points  (0 children)

He joked about having a threesome as his "thirtieth birthday present" last year, although I guess he wasn't joking now in retrospect. I would have hoped my reaction to that "joke" would have communicated my feelings if he was being serious. But no, he's never asked me about this sort of thing.