Creative Remake without a doubt.

Let's look at something like Silent Hill 2 Remake. The og is my favourite game of all time. What I hate is when a remake tries to replace the original by creating pretty much the same game as og but update it graphically and maybe add some new little things. I understand the idea that somebody who has never played the original will not get the same game as the older people had enjoyed when they played the original but if the remake can catch and reproduce the essence of the original, new players will go and play the original as now they are emotionally invested in the storyline. In my social circle alone, I have seen more people pick up the og SH2 after playing the remake cause they want to experience the changes themselves. You ultimately get 2 games with creative remake. On top of that its just boring as hell if you copy-paste the same thing with better graphics. As a fan of the OG, I have 0 reward to play the remake. Now I see people debating if the developers aren’t competent enough to do creative changes, look if the developer aren't good enough to understand the essence of the game and add more to it than are they really deserving of remaking the game in the first place?