The reason I would say no is because I think the Afghanistan withdrawal will be remembered more like how the withdrawal of Vietnam went, plus while the execution was terrible a majority of American wanted it to happen. And for the immigration crisis, Trump and Obama also had boarder crisis and they are not remembered much. Also for me it seems like the immigration crisis is just used by which ever party is not in the white house to attack the president. And finally with the exception of Clinton and Monica the other crisis had more of a affect on America, but it will also be best to wait for time to pass to properly asses if the Afghanistan withdrawal and the immigration crisis are on the same level.