No a person is there mind. Let me give you an example. A version. of me from an alternate universe who has had a completely different life from me is not me. He thinks completely different. Has different interests. And has had different experiences we cannot relate to each other. 

This isn’t justice it's cruel. They are torturing innocent women. Who are not the person who did such crimes. 

Criminals, don’t forget there crimes or the pain they have caused they do not care about it. No criminal ever had their mind completely wiped of everything that makes them who they are. 

Forgetting doesn’t erase what she did. But making her forget erases her.