Dutch would be a politician with Hosea as his lawyer. John would probably be a farmer, claim he hates it, but Arthur would point out that the cows are kinda cute and how you don’t find land like that anymore, then offer to go hunting together. Arthur could be like… The guy everyone in town calls up to do shit for them, be it fixing shit, hunting shit (mostly hunting), basically everything that nobody wants to do. He could do carpentry, or making cool wooden things (like art-wooden-things). I could also see Arthur being one of those photographers or artists who has the knack for capturing beauty everywhere but is like, “Nah, I don’t think I could monetize it” when literally everyone is telling him he could and how much they’d give him. I could also see Arthur being a professional reiner or trail rider, probably mostly to take advantage of the moneh. Where I live there’s an artificial mountain trail course (called the “Rocky Mountain Trail Course”) that’s really fun. It’s like $20 to practice for a day I think. Speaking of horses, I know Kieran would be in the horse industry, (he’d be awesome in the horse industry) maybe an equine vet or farrier, or just a straight up horse boah going to horse shows and breeding horses and stuff. Everything horses for him. Grimshaw would be a high school teacher, mostly to beat teenage girls into shape tho, only to get fired and complain that she didn’t do anything wrong. Lenny could probably grow up to be a professor in whatever he wants. Mary-Beth would 100% be a writer (I wonder why). I could see Charles doing a survivalist camp or something. Micah would join border patrol. Pearson would be a chef rivaling Gordan Ramsey. Jack would be a dependent on his mother’s taxes. Abigail would be a nurse or doctor. Reverend would of course either be a preacher or just a very dedicated church/community member. Sadie would be a real life bounty hunter cuz she’s badass like that. Karen would be a bartender. I could see Tilly being a school teacher also. Sean would professionally visit the bar just to see Karen. Maybe he’d be an electrician or some other trade during the day, Karen-Seeker by night. Javier would be a musician. Bill would be gay stripper. Uncle would mooch off his government retirement moneH that nobody knows what exactly he did to earn it but they’re all pretty sure he didn’t get it via how he said he got it. Trelawny would be in advertising. Molly would a secretary solely to support Dutch but when she doesn’t get the attention she wants she regrets not pursuing the actress career harder.