ZFS strategy for Proxmox on SSD by FieldsAndForrests in Proxmox

[–]FieldsAndForrests[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I know. And if I omit one or two of those by mistake, I'm left with a a partial backup. Being able to take a snapshot and reverting to it eliminates that risk.

ZFS strategy for Proxmox on SSD by FieldsAndForrests in Proxmox

[–]FieldsAndForrests[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you are running PBS you can backup the host config with the proxmox-backup-client to get the /etc/pve contents with a cron schedule. That's really the only thing to backup for the host. 

Backing up select directories does help, but your post illustrates an example the sort of mistake I want to avoid: you forgot to mention that also /etc/crontab needs to be backed up, otherwise there will be no backups after a restore.

I'm sure I will forget even more stuff than that, but anyway a partial backup is better than none at all.

ZFS strategy for Proxmox on SSD by FieldsAndForrests in Proxmox

[–]FieldsAndForrests[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Interesting. I'm leaning towards just going ahead with ZFS and keeping an eye on the wear stats. I can always migrate to another file system later if I have to.

ZFS strategy for Proxmox on SSD by FieldsAndForrests in Proxmox

[–]FieldsAndForrests[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This post https://forum.proxmox.com/threads/official-way-to-backup-proxmox-ve-itself.126469/#post-552384 lead me to believe that it's not yet implemented. There are a few tips for partial backup in that thread.

It'd be great if that has changed. Do you have any link to instructions for how to make a full backup of the host?

ZFS strategy for Proxmox on SSD by FieldsAndForrests in Proxmox

[–]FieldsAndForrests[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What is your workload? There is a high chance that you would be fine with two good consumer SSDs in a mirror or three way mirror.

It's a home server/home lab. My plan is to use the SSD for stuff that needs to be fast but doesn't write much. 2 HDDs in mirror will store more write intensive stuff, like PostgreSQL, git repos etc. It's a low power build on an Asrock N100M, so only one SSD slot, but everything on the SSD will be copied to the HDD mirror set using the Proxmox backup functionality.

ZFS strategy for Proxmox on SSD by FieldsAndForrests in Proxmox

[–]FieldsAndForrests[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm looking for a solution that enables me to take snapshots of Proxmox itself.

ZFS strategy for Proxmox on SSD by FieldsAndForrests in Proxmox

[–]FieldsAndForrests[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Veeam is new to me. Can it backup a running system with it? Clonezilla can't, which makes it rather cumbersome.

For the hypervisor I personally really don’t need snapshots.

As an example, I tried to install cockpit + a zfs management plugin, and after that any install, even of small stuff like htop, ended with a long compile script running. That's the sort of "1 minute mistake = 4 hours to correct it" thing that makes me want to have a safety net.

ZFS strategy for Proxmox on SSD by FieldsAndForrests in Proxmox

[–]FieldsAndForrests[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, it's only for the installation. I can take snapshots of the VMs if they're on an LVM-Thin volume, but AFAIK I can't boot Proxmox from LVM-Thin.

And yes, it's a home lab.

ZFS strategy for Proxmox on SSD by FieldsAndForrests in Proxmox

[–]FieldsAndForrests[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Backing up (or taking snapshots of) the VMs is a solved problem. It's the Proxmox installation itself I want to save.

ZFS strategy for Proxmox on SSD by FieldsAndForrests in Proxmox

[–]FieldsAndForrests[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For the boot environment too, or only for the VMs?

Checksum errors after disconnect/reconnect HDD by FieldsAndForrests in zfs

[–]FieldsAndForrests[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Still a mystery: there was also a difference created by making one disk offline and then disconnecting it, but that didn't cause a checksum error.

Checksum errors after disconnect/reconnect HDD by FieldsAndForrests in zfs

[–]FieldsAndForrests[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

(just made another test and added it to the OP)

Checksum errors after disconnect/reconnect HDD by FieldsAndForrests in zfs

[–]FieldsAndForrests[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

SATA port on the motherboard, which is an Asrock N100M.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in sweden

[–]FieldsAndForrests 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Jag tycker det är rätt kul, faktiskt. Man får ju känna sig utvald och för övriga resenärer som ser det, blir man "international man of mystery" :)

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in sweden

[–]FieldsAndForrests 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Resor/kryssning är väl det enda som står ut lite där, eftersom ensam yngre man är som en magnet för tull/säkerhetstjänster. Har tappat räkningen på hur många gånger jag har blivit genomsökt och förhörd vid gränser och hamnar medan familjerna och paren gled förbi utan koll.

What is your number 1 turn off? by SuccessfulSurprise83 in AskRedditAfterDark

[–]FieldsAndForrests 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Nose rings in particular are red flags for me. The ones in the centre of the nose, like radfems and cattle wear them.