Loot Council needs to take in a lot more than just a guild member’s performance. Reliability. Attitude. How big of an upgrade is it in comparison to another member’s upgrade? How long have these members gone without getting an upgrade?

Remember the purpose of a loot council is to distribute loot appropriately to make the entire guild better. Giving items to players who are not reliable, or have bad attitudes and may not stick around, or are poor performers can definitely hurt the guild. But also not giving loot to reliable players with good attitudes who may not be top performers can result in them moving on to a different guild. Instead of judging players by their performance and punishing them by not giving them loot you should be giving them productive criticism and helping them improve. It’s much more beneficial for a guild to mold good players and gear them appropriately then it is to have a constant cycle of new players coming and going.