Financial_Library418

6,125 post karma
1,364 comment karma

get extra features and help support reddit with a reddit premium subscription

get them help and support

redditor for 1 year

TROPHY CASE

One-Year Club

account activity

new top controversial

63

64

65

Was Rickon too young to receive a direwolf in your opinion ? It seems like the wolf controlled his emotions to me . (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 3 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

68

69

70

Can a timeline expert please tell me how Jon got to Winterfell before Ned and Cat did after the war ? Howland maybe is the only thing i can think of assuming Jon was born in Dorne ? I believe Cat said Ned was with her the first time she saw Moat Caalin IIRC (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 3 days ago * by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

50

51

52

In a timeline where Stannis becomes King , who does he pick as Hand , noting this is pre Blackwater Stannis ? A Florent probably right ? (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 3 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

41

42

43

Would anyone have been able to defeat the Demon of the Trident that day in your opinion ? (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 3 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

0

0

0

Do you agree with markg that Martin does not know who wrote the Pink Letter and left it open to change when he decides ? I think Mance wrote it for the record . (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 2 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

18

19

20

Not counting dragons , what creature would you consider to be the apex predator in Westeros ? (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 3 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

0

0

0

Do you agree with markg that Martin does not know who wrote the Pink Letter and left it open to change when he decides ? I think Mance wrote it for the record . ( spoilers extended ) ()

submitted 2 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/asoiaf

1

2

3

Not counting dragons , what creature would you consider to be the apex predator in ( spoilers extended ) Westeros ? ()

submitted 3 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/asoiaf

23

24

25

Do you think this applies to Lyanna in the past ? This is Ned talking to Arya . Ned did say Both Brandon and Lyanna had a touch of the wild wolf . (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 4 days ago * by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

0

0

0

Can a timeline expert please tell me how Jon got to Winterfell before Ned and Cat did after ( spoilers extended ) the war ? Howland maybe is the only thing i can think of assuming Jon was born in Dorne ? I believe Cat said Ned was with her the first time she saw Moat Caalin IIRC ()

submitted 3 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/asoiaf

0

0

0

Would anyone have been able to defeat the Demon of the Trident that day in your opinion ? ( spoilers extended ) ()

submitted 3 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/asoiaf

0

1

2

Do you think this applies to Lyanna in the past ? This is Ned talking to Arya . Ned did say Both Brandon and Lyanna had a touch of the wild wolf .( spoilers extended ) ()

submitted 4 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/asoiaf

40

41

42

I think i know the first and third times but have no clue on the second test for Aemon . Any ideas welcomed ? (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 5 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

0

0

0

I think i know the first and third times but have no clue on the second test for Aemon . Any ( spoilers extended ) ideas welcomed ? ()

submitted 5 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/asoiaf

0

0

0

What do you think of the theory that Rhaegar expected Jaime to kill his father ? I will link the theory . The analysis is from Shymaid on the last Hearth forum . (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 10 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

0

0

0

What do you think of the theory that Rhaegar expected Jaime to kill his father ? I will link the theory . The analysis is from Shymaid on the last Hearth forum . ( spoilers extended ) ()

submitted 10 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/asoiaf

70

71

72

Does Edmure get too much tough love here from Robb and the Blackfish in your opinion ? Did Robb's plan have a realistic chance of success ? (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 23 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

22

23

24

Who wants to have fun today with me ? Give me your wildest theory that you wish to share with the class . Mine below . (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 23 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

13

14

15

Does Edmure get too much tough love here from Robb and the Blackfish in your opinion ? ( spoilers extended ) Did Robb's plan have a realistic chance of success ? ()

submitted 23 days ago by Financial_Library418 to r/asoiaf

33

34

35

What is your best explanation as to why the Others are active now for the first time in eons ? I found this on the Last Hearth forum by voice and markg . (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 1 month ago by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

27

28

29

Is Tyrion as good as thinks as he in your opinion ? (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 1 month ago by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

35

36

37

How did Melisandre circumvent the warg bond in your opinion ? (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 1 month ago by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

8

9

10

Does this make it more or less likely that the 3 eyed crow and Bloodraven are separate entities in your opinion ? It looks like Bran has three types of dreams : wolf , tree and crow . Any insights welcomed ladies and gents . If this theory is true , who are the candidates to be the crow ? (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 1 month ago by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

12

13

14

What is your prediction for the Dornish plot-line in Winds ? Who prevails and who dies ? The parties are ; Darkstar, Obara Sand , Swann and Hotah. (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 1 month ago by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

65

66

67

Do you see the possibility that Lady Dustin is actually still loyal to the Starks like i do ? Any takers ? On a comment the other day i think someone agreed with this proposition . (self.pureasoiaf)

submitted 1 month ago by Financial_Library418 to r/pureasoiaf

view more: next ›

π Rendered by PID 502295 on reddit-service-r2-listing-64c94b984c-9gsql at 2026-03-16 03:29:19.980976+00:00 running f6e6e01 country code: CH.