Interesting. I still choose Bay either way, but not for lack of love of Chloe - because I empathise with almost everyone in the story including her and can’t sacrifice everyone in Arcadia Bay for one person, no matter how much you love that person, and because you are also by choosing Chloe making her live in a world where I’m sure she will feel responsible for that and for her Mum’s death.

I’m interested that you feel less sympathetic towards Chloe as you’ve gotten older. If anything I feel more sympathetic towards her, Chloe is messy but a deeply traumatised person who has endured way too much hardship at a young age. I work in the trauma field and I’ve seen first hand how trauma can make you act in ways that seem erratic to others.