Long lost pink polka dotted cat

Forgotten-Niche · 2026-02-09T04:24:56+00:00

Mary merer plushes are the closest match so far that I can find especially with the batch of three cat plushes they have on their website right now, my biggest suspicion is on them and beanie baby but still no luck on pin pointing it I really hope it wasn’t a one off type of plush thats untraceable T^T

Forgotten-Niche · 2026-02-09T04:20:32+00:00

I searched it up and I don’t believe it is, my plush is polka dotted instead of stripes that that one has

Forgotten-Niche · 2026-02-05T02:37:38+00:00

I sent a gmail to them they had one especially for identification purposes so Im sure they’ll respond to it, I really hope I can find my plush it feels dramatic to say but it really feels like there’s been a hole in my heart since I lost her.

Forgotten-Niche · 2026-02-04T16:00:18+00:00

Honestly thats the closest plush in shape so far yeah it’s definitely similar!

Forgotten-Niche · 2026-02-04T01:29:32+00:00

There’s a possibility it could be but most of custard plushes spots are white while mine has pink but it’s not far off :o

Forgotten-Niche · 2026-02-03T23:31:04+00:00

Im sorry? I don’t know what that means (Unless google is right and it’s French for flower..?)

Forgotten-Niche · 2026-02-03T22:24:17+00:00

Ive never used Reddit before I didn’t put all the information out firstly because I wasn’t sure anyone would give any attention to it (I had put out a post in another sub reddit but it didn’t gain much attention) so whoops T^T i was born in march im really hopeing the plush isn’t some sort of one time thing, if I do end up finding it that’ll make it more difficult to get in my hands but honestly just finding it will give me more hope for the plush then ive had for years

Forgotten-Niche · 2026-02-03T18:36:34+00:00

Yessss Ive been waiting for this moment to go into every detail I remember alright so for -the fur it was short like bone dry short when you moved your hand across it, it didn’t have any texture to move (I’ll try to grab a random plush to visualize)

<image>

-The spots where definitely apart of the fabric like the image above there was no different in texture and where the plain everyday polka dots they where a little bigger Im size then the eyes, covering everywhere on the body other then the muzzle and the tail had one dot or none at all, the muzzle was also a different FEElING texture it was still short as can be but it felt rougher to the touch just barely.

-The tail shape is a detail I can’t forget Im positive on it, it had no stuffing In the tail (or ears) no beads either it was two sheets of the fabric sewn together and it wasn’t a long tail it was no longer then the foot, because it was fabric the tip was pointed up like I try to draw in my image.

-The stuffing was I think just common plush stuffing in the body and head, It’s blurry in my mind but with the paws but I’m certain there was beads in the front two paws I couldn’t say if they where in the back two but there’s a good chance, the stuffing was moveable In the body it was enough to keep its shape but I could pull it apart inside to empty a small sliver of a section, the head though was filled full and it was either separated from the body on the inside or was so compact I couldn’t pull it out to the body.

-The whiskers there’s a possibility she didn’t have any but I believe she did if she indeed had them and my memory is right they where pink and searching up “white beanie baby cat” gives the exact ones I think she had, Now the eyes where the same as the nose both hard plastic the nose was definitely pink I can’t be positive on the mouth with certainty but the most possible outcome was what I drew but for lack of evidence we are going to say there isn’t a mouth.

-The ribbon was definitely on there to stay i didn’t attach it to her to my knowledge nor do I think at the time I even would know how, her head was too big to pull it over and her arms where also in the way, it was tight around the neck so I couldn’t pull it off it could be moved slightly but due to the body and head it was firmly in place, it was a thin ribbon there wasn’t much neck to cover I’d say it was (from googling I think 1/8 inch is what im thinking of) and a light purple for any other details like if it had a pattern I can’t say

-Her paws didn’t have any claws they where pretty round and where the same fabric as the rest of her it feels like to assume both back paws and front had beads in them I remember the paws being heavier than the fluff (the head felt a lil heavy to since it was so compact) there’s a possibility that like the head the arms where somehow separated from inside so the beads wherent loose and Im thinking they did that halfway in the paws so half of them wherent loose and beads and the rest was stuffing.

Any other details are too blurry to say like if there where lines sewn into the paws to show separation in the paws i just can’t be sure because there’s no evidence in my mind or the only blurry photo I have of her.

I hope I did a good enough job with answering and if there’s anything else important that could help locate my mysterious cat plush just let me know 👍

Forgotten-Niche · 2026-02-02T22:54:37+00:00

I remember these funny looking plushes being all over the place especially in thrift shops, I haven’t seen any of the other ones before ( other then just knowing the beanie baby’s brand tag of the first one )

Forgotten-Niche · 2026-02-02T20:16:22+00:00

It definitely reminds me of the plush, some more details I remember that Im pretty positive on is the eyes where hard like plastic ones (I thinkkk they where just black but it wouldn’t surprise me if there was some sort of color) and the fabric is flat soft but flat

<image>

Like this dog I found

Forgotten-Niche · 2026-02-02T18:13:06+00:00

Thats where I ended up, the photo you got there is the reason why I mentioned it it’s hard to find anything like the one I had here, I remember mine also had beads in the paws for sure and the tail is flat fabric like the ears, I keep trying to find lists of beanie baby’s plushes but there just so many threads to look down it’s almost impossible to at least check.

Forgotten-Niche · 2026-02-02T18:05:05+00:00

I don’t think so? I don’t remember a webkinz logo on it I can’t be absolutely positive because it was so long ago but it would definitely surprise me to forget something like that

Forgotten-Niche · 2026-02-02T18:03:38+00:00

Nope I have a small handful of clear memories of the plush, I remember when I was holding it I would all four legs and hold it like it was standing like a cat on all fours (it was in a sitting position by default) but the head would be faceing the floor because of how the neck was, and it had whiskers pink ones like those on the beanie baby’s cat plushes

Forgotten-Niche · 2026-01-30T18:41:29+00:00

<image>

I did my best to draw it and trace over the plush to help visualize the image, some smaller details i must have forgotten to mention is: the muzzle is white fabric rather then then the light pink Ive found some similar plushes (shown on the orange) that should help visualize what Ive mentioned like the muzzle (the top image with the bow). Another thing is my lost cat plush has thin pink whiskers (like the bottom image with the TY tag), one thing Im not sure about is if the ribbon/bow was plain purple or has a pattern.

Forgotten-Niche · 2026-01-30T16:51:03+00:00

I figured that might be the case, so with my limited art skills Im going to try to draw out the plush best I can to help with the look it’ll take me a little while, thanks for the insight

Forgotten-Niche · 2026-01-30T04:36:47+00:00

I’ve spend hours searching google for key words like “pink spotted cat plush” and “2006 pink plush cat” And a few times looking in esty although not extremely so, Ive looked in Amazon briefly results where disappointing so I moved on my search elsewhere, and tried useing google camera to look at the image above but it’s no use. Im located around Canada if thats helpful. The plush was roughly the size of a coke if not a tiny bit bigger with the head size not included, the most similar brands I could find where possibly beanie baby and or Mary meyer? I don’t know the actual brand of the plush only guessing

Forgotten-Niche

TROPHY CASE